Buyary Home Logo

All the Reviews in One Score

On Cloudflyer 5

76
BUYARY SCORE

Firm, stable daily trainer with plush upper but heavy, stiff ride—best for recovery and support.

The On Cloudflyer 5 arrives as a no-nonsense stability shoe—think armored cloud for tired heels—aimed at runners needing reliable medial support, 31mm heel / 21–22mm forefoot stack, and a forgiving rocker for long miles. Experts and users agree the dual-density Helion™ midsole delivers controlled landings but many note a firmer rearfoot and muted energy return that dull tempo days. The plush engineered mesh and 3D-molded heel counter earn praise for comfort and lockdown, though forum chatter flags a tighter forefoot fit. At $170 you’re buying structure over bounce; more user data is needed before a definitive verdict.

Large Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image

Find Yours

The Scoreboard

Does this improve your life? Considers, health, habits, and environmental impact.

85
FIT
78
EXPERTS
TBD
USERS
78
VALUE

Benefits

🛡️
Stable landings

Wide platform and firmer heel keep foot steady on long runs and recovery days.

☁️
Protective cushioning

Dual-density Helion™ soaks up impact, reducing achiness during high-mileage training.

👟
Smooth toe-off

Rocker geometry and softer forefoot create an easy, confident forefoot transition.

🪶
Plush step-in

Re-engineered collar and engineered mesh give cozy, breathable comfort from first wear.

Reliable support

Secure 3D heel counter and medial contouring reduce roll and aid injury recovery.

Trade-Offs

🥾
Harsh heel landings

Firm rearfoot feels sharp on heel strikes, causing soreness after longer runs.

⚖️
Feels heavy running

Noticeable weight makes fast workouts feel sluggish and tires legs sooner.

🔒
Tighter forefoot fit

Narrower top/front can press toes, creating hotspots or pulling heels during long days.

Product Image

Alternatives

The Cloudflyer 5 delivers confident, cushioned rides with stable heel landings, though its firm midsole and relatively heavy feel can make faster workouts or racing feel sluggish; runners who want quicker reps may lean toward lightweight neutral trainers, while those wanting firmer, mechanical control might prefer medial-post stability shoes.
Circle

Join the Circle

Where real meets deal

Know what's worth buying-and when.
Tips, special offers, and rewards for buying and sharing.

Document Icon

Publications

4 LEADING PUBLICATION REVIEWS


78
Logo of RunRepeat

Carlos Sánchez from RunRepeat highlights a deeply mixed but thoughtful take on the On Cloudflyer 5: he praises its premium construction, plush upper, excellent stability, breathability, and durability, calling it the best Cloudflyer to date for casual wear and runners who need support. However, he’s clearly frustrated by the shoe’s heavy weight and notably firm Helion midsole, backed by lab measurements showing low shock absorption (108 SA) and poor energy return (48.3%), which make the ride feel flat and sluggish for performance runs. Unique insights include precise lab data (stack heights, durometer values, bend stiffness, traction scores) and detailed teardown observations about the dual-density midsole and extended firmer foam into the medial arch—explaining why it’s so stable yet so stiff. Overall, he recommends it for comfort-and-stability seekers but warns performance-focused runners to look elsewhere.

By Carlos Sánchez
October 31, 2024
77
Logo of Doctors of Running

Matt Klein from DOCTORS OF RUNNING highlights the On Cloudflyer 5 as a firmer, guidance-focused stability daily trainer that improves on the Cloudflyer 4 but keeps On’s characteristic stiffness. He praises the wider, comfortable upper and smoother forefoot transition, calling it excellent for walking and all‑day wear and better for midfoot guidance than the prior model. Criticisms center on a clunky, overly firm rearfoot—sharp heel bevel and posterior flare—that makes rearfoot landings uncomfortable and limits the shoe to easy paces and shorter distances; outsole durability is only average. Klein offers specific, actionable fixes (reduce flare/soften heel) and explains in technical detail how foam firmness and platform geometry create stability, making this review especially informative for runners who prefer a high‑drop, firmer ride. Overall: a thoughtful, measured endorsement for those seeking a stable, firm trainer, not for runners wanting plush or fast shoes.

By Matthew Klein
78
Logo of RunRepeat

Carlos Sánchez from RunRepeat highlights a deeply mixed but thoughtful take on the On Cloudflyer 5: he praises its premium construction, plush upper, excellent stability, breathability, and durability, calling it the best Cloudflyer to date for casual wear and runners who need support. However, he’s clearly frustrated by the shoe’s heavy weight and notably firm Helion midsole, backed by lab measurements showing low shock absorption (108 SA) and poor energy return (48.3%), which make the ride feel flat and sluggish for performance runs. Unique insights include precise lab data (stack heights, durometer values, bend stiffness, traction scores) and detailed teardown observations about the dual-density midsole and extended firmer foam into the medial arch—explaining why it’s so stable yet so stiff. Overall, he recommends it for comfort-and-stability seekers but warns performance-focused runners to look elsewhere.

By Carlos Sánchez
October 31, 2024
77
Logo of Doctors of Running

Matt Klein from DOCTORS OF RUNNING highlights the On Cloudflyer 5 as a firmer, guidance-focused stability daily trainer that improves on the Cloudflyer 4 but keeps On’s characteristic stiffness. He praises the wider, comfortable upper and smoother forefoot transition, calling it excellent for walking and all‑day wear and better for midfoot guidance than the prior model. Criticisms center on a clunky, overly firm rearfoot—sharp heel bevel and posterior flare—that makes rearfoot landings uncomfortable and limits the shoe to easy paces and shorter distances; outsole durability is only average. Klein offers specific, actionable fixes (reduce flare/soften heel) and explains in technical detail how foam firmness and platform geometry create stability, making this review especially informative for runners who prefer a high‑drop, firmer ride. Overall: a thoughtful, measured endorsement for those seeking a stable, firm trainer, not for runners wanting plush or fast shoes.

By Matthew Klein
Play TV Icon

YouTube

5 LEADING EXPERT & INFLUENCER REVIEWS


77
Youtube IconFlawless Physio | Shoe Reviews

Flawless Physio praises the On Cloudflyer 5's firm, dual-density Helion™ setup and broad platform for solid stability and heel control, but tones enthusiasm—calling it chunky, stiff underfoot, and better for support/recovery than speed. Useful, expert-led guidance with measured praise and clear caveats.

November 17, 2024
77
Youtube IconFleet Feet

Brandon with Fleet Feet finds the On Cloudflyer 5 a measured, reliable stability trainer—stable, wide-platform ride with plush engineered mesh, 31/21mm stack, and secure 3D heel clip—best for walking, easy miles, and fans of firmer On shoes; criticized for being firmer/heavier than expected.

August 23, 2024
77
Youtube IconFlawless Physio | Shoe Reviews

Flawless Physio praises the On Cloudflyer 5's firm, dual-density Helion™ setup and broad platform for solid stability and heel control, but tones enthusiasm—calling it chunky, stiff underfoot, and better for support/recovery than speed. Useful, expert-led guidance with measured praise and clear caveats.

November 17, 2024
77
Youtube IconFleet Feet

Brandon with Fleet Feet finds the On Cloudflyer 5 a measured, reliable stability trainer—stable, wide-platform ride with plush engineered mesh, 31/21mm stack, and secure 3D heel clip—best for walking, easy miles, and fans of firmer On shoes; criticized for being firmer/heavier than expected.

August 23, 2024
77
Youtube IconFlawless Physio | Shoe Reviews

Flawless Physio praises the On Cloudflyer 5's firm, dual-density Helion™ setup and broad platform for solid stability and heel control, but tones enthusiasm—calling it chunky, stiff underfoot, and better for support/recovery than speed. Useful, expert-led guidance with measured praise and clear caveats.

November 17, 2024
77
Youtube IconFleet Feet

Brandon with Fleet Feet finds the On Cloudflyer 5 a measured, reliable stability trainer—stable, wide-platform ride with plush engineered mesh, 31/21mm stack, and secure 3D heel clip—best for walking, easy miles, and fans of firmer On shoes; criticized for being firmer/heavier than expected.

August 23, 2024

Social

1 INFLUENCER REVIEW


72
Instagram IconRyan’s Running Reviews

Ryan’s Running Reviews notes the Cloudflyer 5 as On’s max-cushion stability daily trainer—positioned for runners who want extra compression and support without moving into the heavier super-trainer category. The clip is informative and measured, listing comparisons across the lineup rather than gushing; tone is practical and mildly approving. Overall consensus: the reviewer treats the Cloudflyer 5 as a reliable, well‑cushioned stability option for everyday miles—recommended for runners needing support and plushness, but presented as one choice among many rather than an unequivocal favorite.

June 7, 2025
Forum Icon

Forum Reviews

CUSTOMER REVIEWS FROM 1 FORUM


25
Logo of Reddit

Reddit discussions about the On Cloudflyer 5 are largely negative, with many long-time users disappointed by a tighter, less plush redesign compared with prior versions. Users report the fit feels narrower across the top and front and the cushioning is firmer, reducing comfort and prompting returns. Some say the changes make the shoe less appealing for those who favored earlier models, with a few planning to skip or exchange rather than upgrade. Overall sentiment skews critical, centered on design and comfort regressions rather than praise for new features.

Few comments

Scales Icon

In-Depth Review

Highlights Icon

Highlights

  • Dual-density Helion midsole
    Firm heel, softer forefoot for control
  • Wide platform and 3D heel counter
    Designed to stabilize landings and lock heel
  • Forefoot rocker with high stack
    Designed to smooth heel-to-toe transition
  • Breathable engineered mesh and collar
    Comfortable, well-ventilated upper
  • Reliable wet traction
    Reliable grip on wet concrete
  • Recycled-content upper (women's)
    Company states 72% recycled polyester
Considerations Icon

Considerations

  • Firm, stiff rearfoot
    Rearfoot feels harsh on heel strikes
  • Heavy overall weight
    Noticeable mass limits speedwork
  • Tighter forefoot and vamp fit
    Narrower top/front can cause hotspots
  • Muted energy return
    Sluggish push-off and low rebound
  • Not suited for faster paces
    Optimized for easy paces and recovery
  • Limited width options
    Only regular width offered

Real-world feedback for the Cloudflyer 5 is still limited, so take early impressions as informed first-looks rather than gospel. From On—known for its engineered cushioning and Swiss-leaning precision—this model positions itself as a premium, stability-focused daily trainer aimed at overpronators, walkers, and runners seeking protective long‑mile comfort. It pairs a dual-density Helion™ midsole (firmer heel, softer forefoot) with a wide platform and 3D-molded heel counter for planted landings and guided support, trading plushness for structure compared with prior Cloudflyer iterations. You’ll notice a 31mm heel / ~21–22mm forefoot stack, a 9–10mm drop, and a weight that sits toward the heavier side—features that favor recovery runs and steady paces over tempo sessions. If you prioritize stability, breathability, and a firm, confidence-inspiring ride, this shoe merits a close read of the sections ahead—start with the midsole, then see how weight, fit, and rocker affect your stride.

Product Image

Weight (per shoe)

At roughly 300–320g (men) and 250g (women), the Cloudflyer 5 sits on the heavier side for a stability trainer—noticeable in longer tempo sessions where reviewers call the shoe clunky and energy return dampened. The mass contributes to the planted, durable feel that rehab-focused users love, but it also limits speed: experts suggest it’s best reserved for easy runs, walking, and recovery days when stability wins over speed, not for races.

Product Image

Stack height and heel-to-toe drop

With a 31mm heel and ~21–22mm forefoot (9–10mm drop), the Cloudflyer 5 favors heel-strikers and provides a protective, elevated platform that smooths transitions via its forefoot rocker. The geometry promotes an easy roll from heel to toe, helping long efforts feel less jarring, but combined with firm Helion™ foam it can make push-offs feel muted rather than springy. For daily miles and recovery, the stack is a win; if you chase liveliness, expect a deliberate ride.

Product Image

Upper construction and breathability

The engineered mesh (women’s version uses 72% recycled polyester) and reworked collar deliver immediate comfort and surprisingly good airflow—tests peg breathability around 4/5—while a semi-gusseted tongue keeps debris out. Fit feedback is split: many applaud the plush step-in and secure heel lock, but forum chatter warns of a tighter forefoot/vamp versus older models, which may create hotspots for some. Overall, the upper balances sustainability, comfort, and ventilation with a caveat on fit.

Product Image

Stability and medial support

The Cloudflyer 5 leans into guided support with a wide platform and 3D-molded heel counter that lock the foot and limit inward roll without an aggressive medial post. Bench numbers (lower SA) and teardown notes confirm that firmer medial foam extends into the arch, delivering predictable control; experts praise the secure heel clip and walkers report less ankle wobble. That said, the approach trades a little comfort for structure—excellent for rehab or overpronators seeking a confident, planted feel.

Product Image

Midsole cushioning and firmness

If you like firm protection, the Cloudflyer 5’s dual-density Helion™ midsole is a clear statement: a 28 HA heel layer for controlled landings and a softer forefoot for smoother roll-offs. Lab measures show low shock absorption (108 SA) and a noticeably stiff rearfoot, which reviewers say reduces plushness but boosts durability and stability—great for recovery miles, less fun for tempo work. Brand claims of tuned cushioning hold up in construction, though real-world feedback flags the ride as firmer-than-expected and sometimes too blunt late in long runs.

Product Image

Flexibility and rocker transition

The Cloudflyer 5’s design leans toward a stiff-but-directed feel: lab flex numbers show reduced forefoot bend, yet the built-in rocker geometry and softer forefoot layer still yield a smoother toe-off than the rearfoot suggests. The result is a controlled, guided rollover that’s forgiving on long miles but can feel sluggish during pickups; reviewers agree the transition is pleasant for steady paces, while sprinters will find the lack of snappy rebound limiting.

Conclusion

Early signals are cautious but clear: this shoe bets on structure over squish. The dual-density midsole gives controlled heel landings and a firmer ride that comforts overloaded joints but will feel blunt to those chasing bounce. The wide platform and 3D heel cradle deliver dependable medial support, ideal for rehab or steady miles. With a 31/21–22mm stack and 9–10mm drop you get protected heel-to-toe geometry that favors heel strikers. Expect the mass to show up—its noticeable weight dulls tempo work. The engineered mesh and collar score well for breathable, plush step‑in fit, though the vamp can feel snug. Flex is reduced, yet the rocker yields a smooth, guided rollover for long efforts. If you want durable, structured comfort for recovery and daily training, this is a thoughtful pick; if you crave lively speed, look elsewhere—this shoe is engineered to steady, not sprint.

Feature Scores Icon

Feature Scores

This reflects reviews and ratings from established critics, journalists, and users who have evaluated the item. Their opinions provide a comprehensive assessment.

Performance

Cushioning

4/5

Responsiveness

2/5

Durability

4/5

Traction

4/5

Fit Consistency

3/5

Value

Price to Quality Ratio

4/5

Price Accessibility

3/5

Warranty Support

3/5

Design

Aesthetic Appeal

4/5

Ergonomic Fit

3/5

Upper Craftsmanship

4/5

Health

Breathability

4/5

Arch Support

4/5

Injury Risk Mitigation

4/5

Hypoallergenic Materials

TBD

Safety

Reflective Visibility

2/5

Slip Resistance

4/5

Foot Protection

4/5

Stability Control

5/5

Sustainability

Recycled Materials Use

4/5

Product Longevity

4/5

Packaging Sustainability

TBD

End-of-Life Recyclability

TBD

Experience Style

Ease of Use

4/5

Adjustability

4/5

Customization Options

2/5

Feature Richness

4/5

Specifications Icon

Specifications

This section outlines the product's key facts, covering essential features, details, dimensions, materials, and any unique characteristics that define its functionality and usability.

Performance

Design

Safety

Sustainability

Experience Style

Question Mark Icon

Frequently Asked Questions


6 Questions