Buyary Home Logo

All the Reviews in One Score

AskAri
On Cloudflyer 5

On Cloudflyer 5

68
BUYARY SCOREAverage

Stable, breathable, and supportive, but exceptionally firm and clunky for faster running.

The On Cloudflyer 5 is a steadying “seatbelt” for runners whose feet need guidance, not a sports car for chasing speed. Its wide stability platform, supportive heel, and 9–10mm drop suit mild overpronators, heel strikers, walkers, and recovery runners. On presents it as plush, but expert testing and user feedback point to exceptionally firm cushioning, limited bounce, and a rigid, sometimes clunky transition. The breathable, padded upper and dependable wet grip are genuine strengths, though forefoot fit opinions vary. At $170, it earns its premium more through secure support and all-day versatility than lively performance. Its overall appeal depends on how much you value stability and comfort over softness, lightness, and speed.

On Cloudflyer 5
On Cloudflyer 5
On Cloudflyer 5
On Cloudflyer 5
On Cloudflyer 5
On Cloudflyer 5
On Cloudflyer 5
AskAri

Find Yours

Step 011 of 4 questions

What type of running do you mostly do?

Answer to find your best matches.

The Scoreboard

Does this improve your life? Considers, health, habits, and environmental impact.

68
FIT
75
EXPERTS
TBD
USERS
76
VALUE

Benefits

🛡️
Steady, Secure Landings

Wide platform and molded heel keep feet planted during long walks, recovery runs, and miles.

🌬️
Comfortable All-Day Fit

Plush collar, smooth lining, and breathable mesh make extended wear feel secure without overheating.

🦶
Protective Guided Cushioning

Dual-density foam softens forefoot impact while firmer heel support steadies overpronating feet.

🚶
Easy Walking Support

Rockered geometry rolls you forward smoothly, helping the shoe feel dependable for walking and recovery.

Trade-Offs

🦶
Hard Heel Landings

During heel strikes, the stiff rearfoot can feel jarring and uncomfortable on walks or runs.

🧱
Firm, Flat Ride

Firm foam feels less cushioned and lively, making everyday miles feel harder than expected.

⚖️
Heavy, Clunky Heel

Repeated easy runs can make the substantial heel feel awkward, slowing transitions and tiring your stride.

On Cloudflyer 5

Alternatives

The On Cloudflyer 5 delivers secure, cushioned stability for overpronators, long runs, recovery miles, and walking, though its firm, relatively heavy ride can feel clunky when you want to run fast. Runners prioritizing a lighter, quicker feel may lean toward lightweight stability shoes, while those wanting less guidance might prefer neutral daily trainers with a softer, freer ride.
Circle

Join the Circle

Where real meets deal

Know what's worth buying-and when.
Tips, special offers, and rewards for buying and sharing.

Document Icon

Publications

4 LEADING PUBLICATION REVIEWS


78
Logo of RunRepeat

Carlos Sánchez from RunRepeat highlights a deeply mixed but thoughtful take on the On Cloudflyer 5: he praises its premium construction, plush upper, excellent stability, breathability, and durability, calling it the best Cloudflyer to date for casual wear and runners who need support. However, he’s clearly frustrated by the shoe’s heavy weight and notably firm Helion midsole, backed by lab measurements showing low shock absorption (108 SA) and poor energy return (48.3%), which make the ride feel flat and sluggish for performance runs. Unique insights include precise lab data (stack heights, durometer values, bend stiffness, traction scores) and detailed teardown observations about the dual-density midsole and extended firmer foam into the medial arch—explaining why it’s so stable yet so stiff. Overall, he recommends it for comfort-and-stability seekers but warns performance-focused runners to look elsewhere.

By Carlos Sánchez

October 31, 2024Visit Source →
77
Logo of Doctors of Running

Matt Klein from DOCTORS OF RUNNING highlights the On Cloudflyer 5 as a firmer, guidance-focused stability daily trainer that improves on the Cloudflyer 4 but keeps On’s characteristic stiffness. He praises the wider, comfortable upper and smoother forefoot transition, calling it excellent for walking and all‑day wear and better for midfoot guidance than the prior model. Criticisms center on a clunky, overly firm rearfoot—sharp heel bevel and posterior flare—that makes rearfoot landings uncomfortable and limits the shoe to easy paces and shorter distances; outsole durability is only average. Klein offers specific, actionable fixes (reduce flare/soften heel) and explains in technical detail how foam firmness and platform geometry create stability, making this review especially informative for runners who prefer a high‑drop, firmer ride. Overall: a thoughtful, measured endorsement for those seeking a stable, firm trainer, not for runners wanting plush or fast shoes.

By Matthew Klein

78
Logo of Running Product Reviews

Running Product Reviews praises the On Cloudflyer 5 as a confident, evolutionary update that keeps the franchise’s signature stability and cushioning while refining geometry for a flatter, more stable rearfoot touchdown. The reviewer commends the two-density midsole and Cloudtec elements for delivering a “firm, but protective” ride, and notes the textured rubber outsole, closed mesh upper with an abbreviated saddle, and smooth interior as thoughtful touches that balance traction, durability, and a secure yet comfortable fit. Criticisms are mild: changes are incremental rather than revolutionary, but the shoe is presented as a reliable high‑mileage option suitable for marathon training or everyday wear, and appropriate for runners from low to high arches with neutral to mild overpronation. Overall tone is approving and measured, highlighting practical improvements and consistent performance.

77
Logo of Run to the Finish

RunToTheFinish's Stacey Gross assesses the On Cloudflyer 5 as a solid, practical stability shoe that delivers secure support but falls short of the "plush" cushioning On markets. The reviewer tested the shoe across treadmill, gravel, and extended walking, praising its wider base, locked-in heel counter, improved outsole (fewer trapped rocks), and comfort for long periods standing or daily steps. Criticisms focus on an overall firmer underfoot feel—less bounce or softness than competing stability models—and potential durability concerns for high-wear lugs; the Cloudflyer 5 also isn’t offered in wide widths and is relatively heavy for fast running. Unique insights include the removed speedboard, the perceptible softer heel layer versus firm forefoot, and real-world notes from someone with plantar fasciitis who found it manageable. Overall: dependable daily trainer and support shoe, but not the plush cushion some buyers may expect.

By Stacey Gross

March 18, 2025Visit Source →
Play TV Icon

YouTube

3 LEADING EXPERT & INFLUENCER REVIEWS


74
Youtube IconFlawless Physio | Shoe Reviews

James of Flawless Physio is lukewarm on the On Cloudflyer 5, preferring it for walking over running. He appreciates its very wide platform, firm dual-density Helion™ foam, 10mm drop, roomy forefoot, and supportive heel structure, which may suit some stability needs and conditions such as Achilles or tendon issues. However, he finds it exceptionally rigid, clunky, and awkward through the heel-to-toe transition. The rocker offers some forward assistance, but the firm ride may aggravate forefoot problems like Morton’s neuroma. Overall, it suits people wanting maximum support and a firm feel, but not runners seeking a smooth, lively daily trainer.

December 1, 2024
78
Youtube IconFleet Feet

Brandon gives the On Cloudflyer 5 a moderately positive, practical review. He praises its plush, true-to-size upper, secure heel clip, wide and stable platform, and surprisingly reliable wet-weather grip. However, the ride is notably firm, lacks much bounce, and the shoe’s 10.5-ounce weight makes it better suited to walking, gym use, casual running, and easy three- to four-mile outings than faster training. At $170, it’s a comfortable, dependable stability option—especially for Cloudrunner 2 fans wanting more stack—but not the highly cushioned daily trainer On’s marketing suggests.

August 23, 2024
54
Youtube IconRunIQ

RunIQ is decidedly unimpressed with the On Cloudflyer 5, placing it in D tier. The breathable upper, padded tongue, secure fit, durability, and wide-base stability earn some credit, particularly for walking or slower, supportive miles. However, the shoe’s 11.6-ounce weight and firm dual-density Helion™ midsole make it feel unnecessarily heavy and clunky, with little energy return and an uninspiring push-off. Despite decent shock absorption and outsole wear resistance, RunIQ views it as comfortable enough for walking but a poor choice for runners seeking a lively, effortless ride.

January 2, 2025

Social

1 INFLUENCER REVIEW


72
Instagram IconRyan’s Running Reviews

Ryan’s Running Reviews notes the Cloudflyer 5 as On’s max-cushion stability daily trainer—positioned for runners who want extra compression and support without moving into the heavier super-trainer category. The clip is informative and measured, listing comparisons across the lineup rather than gushing; tone is practical and mildly approving. Overall consensus: the reviewer treats the Cloudflyer 5 as a reliable, well‑cushioned stability option for everyday miles—recommended for runners needing support and plushness, but presented as one choice among many rather than an unequivocal favorite.

June 7, 2025
Forum Icon

Forum Reviews

CUSTOMER REVIEWS FROM 1 FORUM


25
Logo of Reddit

Reddit discussions about the On Cloudflyer 5 are largely negative, with many long-time users disappointed by a tighter, less plush redesign compared with prior versions. Users report the fit feels narrower across the top and front and the cushioning is firmer, reducing comfort and prompting returns. Some say the changes make the shoe less appealing for those who favored earlier models, with a few planning to skip or exchange rather than upgrade. Overall sentiment skews critical, centered on design and comfort regressions rather than praise for new features.

Few comments

Scales Icon

In-Depth Review

Highlights Icon

Highlights

  • •
    Stable Wide Platform
    Designed to support controlled, secure landings.
  • •
    Breathable Padded Upper
    Engineered mesh keeps airflow high during wear.
  • •
    Secure Heel Fit
    Molded heel counter improves rearfoot lockdown.
  • •
    Reliable Wet Traction
    Rubber outsole grips well on wet concrete.
Considerations Icon

Considerations

  • •
    Exceptionally Firm Cushioning
    Firm foam feels less plush and lively.
  • •
    Clunky Heel Transition
    Rigid rearfoot can make landings feel awkward.
  • •
    Heavy For Speed
    Substantial weight limits faster running efforts.
  • •
    Inconsistent Forefoot Fit
    Some users report tightness across the vamp.

On has built a reputation for distinctive, supportive running shoes, and the Cloudflyer 5 targets runners who prioritize guidance over speed. Positioned as a premium stability trainer, it updates the Cloudflyer 4 with dual-density Helion foam, a broader platform, and a softer forefoot for daily miles, recovery runs, walking, and long hours standing. Its 31mm heel stack and 9–10mm drop favor heel strikers, while the structured build helps runners with mild overpronation or those who prefer a planted feel. The tradeoff is notable: roughly 10.6–11.3 ounces in men’s sizing and a firm, less energetic ride than rivals such as the Adrenaline GTS or Arahi. A breathable engineered-mesh upper adds comfort, but fit feedback varies, so examine the heel guidance, rocker transition, and forefoot space closely—the Cloudflyer 5 is less cloud-like than its name suggests, and the following details explain why.

On Cloudflyer 5

Rocker And Flexibility

The shoe rolls forward more than it bends, which suits steady walking and controlled recovery efforts. Its rocker geometry helps offset the firm foam and provides some forward assistance, but testing found it less flexible than average, at roughly 48.3% flexibility versus a 58.6% comparison average. That stiffness reinforces the guided, stable character, yet can make the heel-to-toe transition feel rigid or clunky. Reviewers differ on comfort, but faster runners are unlikely to find the transition especially lively.

On Cloudflyer 5

Upper And Breathability

The upper is one of the Cloudflyer 5’s more successful updates. Its engineered mesh with ventilation holes allows good airflow, earning roughly a 4/5 breathability assessment despite added padding. A plush ankle collar, semi-gusseted tongue, smooth lining, and molded heel cup create a secure, comfortable step-in feel. The women’s version uses substantial recycled polyester content, though specifications vary by source. Feedback is mixed on fit: some find the forefoot roomy, while prior Cloudflyer users report a tighter vamp and less plush fit.

On Cloudflyer 5

Stability And Support

Stability is the shoe’s clearest strength, especially for runners who prefer guidance without a traditional medial post. The wide landing platform, firmer medial foam, and 3D-molded heel counter keep the foot secure, while the extended firm foam helps limit unwanted movement. Its measured torsional resistance of 14.8 N supports that structured feel. This can work well for mild overpronation, heavier runners, or long periods standing, although the rigid rearfoot and sharp heel geometry may feel harsh for some heel strikers.

On Cloudflyer 5

Stack And Heel Drop

The Cloudflyer 5’s geometry favors heel strikers and controlled transitions. A 31 mm heel stack sits above a 21–22 mm forefoot, creating a 9–10 mm drop that reduces calf and Achilles loading for some runners. The rocker helps roll the shoe forward, but the higher heel does not make it soft or especially fluid. Reviewers generally appreciate the protective platform and flatter touchdown, while some find the heel bevel and posterior flare awkward, particularly during slower rearfoot-led running.

On Cloudflyer 5

Weight And Running Pace

This is a support-first shoe rather than a speed-focused trainer. At roughly 10.6–11.3 ounces for men’s sizing and about 8.8 ounces in the listed women’s size, it carries substantial structure underfoot. The broad platform, dense Helion foam, and molded heel contribute to dependable stability, but also create a clunky heel and muted push-off. Reviewers tend to favor it for walking, gym use, recovery, and easy three- to four-mile outings, with limited enthusiasm for speedwork or racing.

On Cloudflyer 5

Midsole Cushioning Feel

The Cloudflyer 5 feels protective but distinctly firm underfoot. Its dual-density Helion™ midsole uses a firmer heel layer, measured around 28.0 HA, with softer foam toward the forefoot, while CloudTec elements and a rocker add some impact management. That setup supports steady easy miles, walking, and recovery, but lab testing found relatively low shock absorption and 48.3% energy return. Experts and reviewers generally agree it lacks bounce, so On’s cushioning language may overstate plushness for runners expecting a lively daily trainer.

Conclusion

The Cloudflyer 5 makes its priorities clear: firm cushioning and dependable control come before speed or softness. Its broad platform, medial guidance, and molded heel provide secure landings, while the 31mm heel and 9–10mm drop suit heel strikers and runners who appreciate structured support. The tradeoff is substantial weight—roughly 10.6–11.3 ounces per men’s shoe—and a rigid heel that experts and users describe as clunky, especially when pushing the pace. Its engineered-mesh upper is breathable and comfortably padded, though forefoot fit feedback is inconsistent. The rocker helps the shoe roll forward, but limited flexibility keeps transitions controlled rather than lively. That makes it a sensible choice for walking, recovery, easy miles, and extended standing—not racing or energetic daily training. The Cloudflyer 5 earns its premium price through stable guidance, secure heel lockdown, and reliable traction, but its muted ride limits broader appeal.

Feature Scores Icon

Feature Scores

This reflects reviews and ratings from established critics, journalists, and users who have evaluated the item. Their opinions provide a comprehensive assessment.

Performance

Cushioning

3/5

Responsiveness

2/5

Durability

3/5

Traction

4/5

Fit Consistency

3/5

Value

Price to Quality Ratio

3/5

Price Accessibility

2/5

Warranty Support

3/5

Design

Aesthetic Appeal

4/5

Ergonomic Fit

4/5

Upper Craftsmanship

4/5

Health

Breathability

4/5

Arch Support

4/5

Injury Risk Mitigation

3/5

Hypoallergenic Materials

2/5

Safety

Reflective Visibility

3/5

Slip Resistance

4/5

Foot Protection

4/5

Stability Control

4/5

Sustainability

Recycled Materials Use

4/5

Product Longevity

3/5

Packaging Sustainability

3/5

End-of-Life Recyclability

2/5

Experience Style

Ease of Use

4/5

Adjustability

4/5

Customization Options

3/5

Feature Richness

4/5

Specifications Icon

Specifications

This section outlines the product's key facts, covering essential features, details, dimensions, materials, and any unique characteristics that define its functionality and usability.

Performance

Value

Design

Safety

Sustainability

Experience Style

Question Mark Icon

Frequently Asked Questions


6 Questions