Buyary Home Logo

All the Reviews in One Score

AskAri
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

84
BUYARY SCOREExcellent

Ultra-fine precision and natural finish impress users despite fragile packaging and quick depletion.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz is the ultimate precision pencil for anyone battling sparse or unruly brows, delivering ultra-fine 1mm strokes that mimic real hairs with enviable ease. Fans and experts alike praise its smooth wax-pigment formula, impressive 12-shade range, and handy built-in spoolie for seamless blending. The retractable tip means no sharpening drama, but users warn of a fragile casing prone to breakage and a surprisingly small product size that depletes fast—making it a premium investment worth handling with care. Its blend of finesse, natural finish, and thoughtful design keeps loyalists hooked despite durability quirks near the end of the day.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz
AskAri

Find Yours

Step 011 of 4 questions

What kind of eyebrow look do you prefer?

Answer to find your best matches.

The Scoreboard

Does this improve your life? Considers, health, habits, and environmental impact.

76
FIT
86
EXPERTS
89
USERS
92
VALUE

Benefits

✏️
Hair-like precision

Ultra-fine wax-and-pigment tip creates realistic brow hairs for confidence and natural appearance.

🪮
Built-in blending tool

Integrated spoolie blends strokes, simplifying grooming and reducing extra product steps daily.

🎨
Natural finish, wide shades

Mineral pigments like iron oxides and mica enable lifelike tones, unlike mono-pigment competitors.

⏱️
Smudge-resistant wear

Waxy emollients and stabilizers (carnauba, hydrogenated oils) help brows resist smudging through sweat.

✨
Confidence to experiment

Precise control reduces makeup anxiety, letting users practice realistic shaping without fear.

Trade-Offs

⚠️
Preservative irritation risk

Phenoxyethanol, caprylyl glycol, hexylene glycol can irritate sensitive skin or disrupt skin microbiome.

🧪
Questioned pigment chemistry

Synthetic pigment use (e.g., ferric ferrocyanide) contrasts eco-leaders' minimally processed, natural colorant approach.

🪨
Mica sourcing risk

Mica mining often carries child-labor and traceability issues; diverges from ethical-sourcing leaders.

🏭
Hydrogenated oil processing

Hydrogenated oils indicate heavy refining and possible palm sourcing, unlike low-impact ingredient leaders.

♻️
Fragile plastic packaging

Reports of cracked casing and spoolies increase product waste and create consumer frustration.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Ingredient Insights

Alternatives

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz nails precise, hairlike strokes and long-lasting definition while depending on wax-based solids, synthetic pigments and preservatives that complicate ingredient integrity and environmental persistence. If you want to preserve natural-looking groomed brows versus trading cleaner formulations, consider water-based tinted brow gels, which use film-forming polymers, or pressed mineral brow powders, built around mineral pigments.
Circle

Join the Circle

Where real meets deal

Know what's worth buying-and when.
Tips, special offers, and rewards for buying and sharing.

Document Icon

Publications

1 LEADING PUBLICATION REVIEWS


88
Logo of TODAY

Katie Jackson from TODAY highlights the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz as a versatile and effective solution for sparse brows, praising its ultra-fine retractable tip that mimics natural hair strokes and a soft, precise spoolie for seamless blending. She appreciates the product’s matte finish and wide shade range, which allows for a natural look tailored to different hair colors. While initially hesitant due to the $23 price tag, Jackson finds the Brow Wiz worth the investment for its ease of use, lasting wear, and ability to create both subtle and bold brow styles. She notes it’s not waterproof but resists smudging well, even through sweat. Unique insights include her comparison to older brow pencils and the product’s ability to inspire makeup experimentation without fear of mistakes. Though she still keeps a cheaper pencil for everyday use, the Brow Wiz earns a place in her beauty routine for its precision and reliability.

By Katie Jackson

August 17, 2021Visit Source →
Play TV Icon

YouTube

9 LEADING EXPERT & INFLUENCER REVIEWS


86
Youtube IconKelly Strack

Kelly Strack praises the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its ultra-fine tip and natural finish, highlighting its ease of use and precise application—ideal for beginners. She notes the smaller spoolie and limited product size but values its natural look. Compared to the newer Brow Definer, Brow Wiz offers a more traditional pencil feel and finer detail, making it a trusted, high-quality choice.

January 24, 2016
86
Youtube Icongirlgetglamorous

girlgetglamorous praises Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its perfect pigment-to-wax ratio and natural-looking shades. She highlights the ultra-fine tip’s versatility, showing how light or heavy pressure creates different effects. The detailed swatches across eight shades offer valuable insights for matching various hair colors, emphasizing the pencil’s smooth, blendable formula.

April 9, 2022
78
Youtube IconMakeup By Megha

Makeup By Megha praises the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its ultra-fine, retractable tip and natural, precise hair-like strokes, highlighting its smooth wax-pigment formula and built-in spoolie for blending. She notes it requires practice and is time-consuming but delivers a subtle, realistic brow, contrasting it with the quicker, bolder Brow Definer.

February 26, 2016
92
Youtube IconZabrena

Zabrena praises the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its precise application, natural-looking hair-like strokes, and excellent quality, though she notes the limited shade range and high price. She enthusiastically recommends the L’Oreal Brow Stylist Definer as a budget-friendly dupe with comparable performance and lasting wear.

December 12, 2018
83
Youtube IconAmea May

Amea May praises the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its ultra-fine tip and natural, hair-like strokes, highlighting its ease of use and effective blending with the built-in spoolie. While impressed by the precise application and color match, she remains uncertain about its premium price after just one use, planning further testing with her mom.

June 30, 2016
82
Youtube IconMeemsCouture

MeemsCouture praises the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its ultra-fine, dual-ended design that creates a natural, hair-like brow look. She appreciates the precise pencil tip and built-in spoolie brush for blending, noting it offers a more natural finish than her previous methods. Minor issues include cap design confusion and missing the brow gel, but overall she finds it effective and plans to explore more products from the line.

January 24, 2013
87
Youtube IconRoxanne Latulippe

Roxanne Latulippe praises the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its ultra-slim, retractable design, precise hair-like strokes, and sturdy packaging that outperforms drugstore alternatives. She highlights its natural finish and ease of blending with the built-in spoolie. While acknowledging the higher price, she enthusiastically recommends it over dupes like NYX’s Micro Brow Pencil.

February 19, 2021
86
Youtube IconAlysa Mara

Alysa Mara praises the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its ultra-fine tip and precise application, ideal for detailed brow work. While she loves both Brow Wiz and Brow Definer, she prefers the Definer for quicker use despite its larger spoolie. Her review balances enthusiasm with practical insights on technique and product differences.

February 23, 2016
92
Youtube IconAmanda Mae

Amanda Mae praises the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its ultra-fine, retractable wax-based tip that creates natural, fuller brows with ease. She values the built-in spoolie for blending and highlights its convenience without sharpening. While she prefers the powder-based Perfect Brow Pencil slightly, she finds both excellent for detailed, natural-looking brows.

July 31, 2020

Social

2 INFLUENCER REVIEWS


87
Instagram IconShalini Padavala

Shalini Padavala highlights her enthusiasm for the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz, praising its subtle, buildable hair-like strokes that suit natural to sculpted brow looks. She also reviews the Dip Brow Gel, noting its high pigmentation and strong hold but warns it can appear too dark and bulky on thick brows, recommending a light hand or a clear gel for beginners. Overall, Shalini strongly recommends the Brow Wiz as a versatile, reliable brow product she would repurchase, while expressing hesitation about the Dip Brow Gel due to its intensity on fuller brows. Her balanced insights offer helpful guidance for different brow types and skill levels.

September 6, 2020
94
Instagram IconAllure Beauty Box

Allure Beauty Box highlights the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz as a longtime favorite, praising its ultra-fine tip for precise, natural-looking hair-like strokes and perfectly balanced pigmentation that’s beginner-friendly. The blend of wax and formula delivers a subtle, natural finish without being too intense. Overall, the reviewer enthusiastically recommends the Brow Wiz for its precision and ease of use, emphasizing its reliability and natural effect. They express genuine affection for the product and encourage followers to try it, signaling strong confidence in its quality and performance.

September 3, 2025
Store Bag Icon

Store Reviews

CUSTOMER REVIEWS FROM 4 STORES


86
Logo of Sephora

Users on Sephora praise the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its natural finish, precise application, and excellent color range that suits various hair tones, including unique shades like caramel for redheads and medium ash for those with lighter brows. Many highlight how the ultra-thin pencil tip allows for hair-like strokes, creating well-defined yet soft brows that blend seamlessly with the included spoolie brush. Reviewers with oily skin appreciate its oil-resistant formula that stays put throughout the day without smudging easily. Mature users especially value how it restores sparse brows without looking overly drawn on. However, customers frequently report frustration with the product’s packaging and quantity. The pencil contains a surprisingly small amount of product, causing it to run out quickly—often within a month of daily use—leading to repeated repurchases that some find costly. Numerous users experience the spoolie brush breaking off or the pencil mechanism failing, with some noting a decline in packaging quality over recent purchases. Several mention that the pencil’s delicate lead breaks easily if extended too far or dropped, which diminishes its durability. Despite these issues, many remain loyal to the formula itself, calling it a holy grail product and irreplaceable in their makeup routine. In summary, Sephora customers love the Brow Wiz’s precision, natural look, and shade variety but urge Anastasia Beverly Hills to improve the packaging sturdiness and increase the product amount to better match its premium price.

4.4 Stars / Many verified reviews

91
Logo of Amazon

Amazon users praise the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its precise, natural-looking application and smooth formula that glides on effortlessly. Reviewers highlight the fine, retractable pencil tip that creates hair-like strokes, allowing for detailed shaping and filling of sparse brows. Many appreciate the extensive shade range, which offers well-pigmented colors that suit various hair tones without appearing too warm or cool. Customers also value the dual-ended design featuring a spoolie brush, which blends the product seamlessly and helps achieve both soft and bold brow looks. Users consistently report that the Brow Wiz lasts throughout the day without smudging or fading, even in humid conditions, maintaining a fresh appearance from morning to evening. The compact, travel-friendly packaging receives positive remarks for convenience, eliminating the need for sharpening. However, several reviewers note the pencil’s thin lead breaks easily and runs out faster than thicker alternatives, which some find frustrating given the product’s premium price. Opinions on value vary, with many considering the quality and performance worth the investment, while others feel it does not justify the cost. Overall, Amazon customers regard the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz as a top-tier eyebrow pencil that delivers precision, longevity, and versatility, making it a staple for those seeking well-defined, natural brows despite minor durability concerns.

4.5 Stars / Many verified reviews

91
Logo of Ulta Beauty

Ulta Beauty reviewers consistently praise the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its precision, natural finish, and ease of use. Users highlight the pencil’s ultra-fine tip that mimics individual brow hairs, allowing for both subtle and dramatic looks without appearing harsh or drawn on. Many appreciate the automatic, retractable design that eliminates sharpening, while the integrated spoolie brush receives frequent mention for blending and grooming brows seamlessly. Reviewers with various hair colors, including challenging shades like red or very light blonde, find suitable color matches that blend naturally. Several customers emphasize the product’s long-lasting wear, noting it stays put throughout the day—even in humid or sweaty conditions—yet removes easily at night. The pencil’s waxy texture and buildable formula earn high marks for creating defined, full brows, especially for those with thinning or sparse hair. Users also share practical tips, such as gently breaking open the casing to access extra product or applying moisturizer beforehand to improve smoothness. However, a notable concern emerges around the product’s packaging durability: many users report the spoolie brush breaking off after minimal use, which frustrates loyal customers and sometimes leads them to seek alternatives despite loving the pencil itself. Some mention the limited amount of product inside the slim pencil, causing it to run out quickly with daily use, which can feel costly over time. A few reviewers also caution about potential eyebrow hair fallout, though this appears less common. Overall, Ulta Beauty customers find the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz indispensable for achieving natural, well-defined brows with precision and ease, while hoping for improvements in the applicator’s sturdiness and product quantity.

4.6 Stars / Many verified reviews

71
Logo of Target

Users on Target praise the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its natural finish, precise application, and excellent color matching across a wide range of shades. Many highlight the pencil’s ultra-slim tip that allows for effortless, hair-like strokes and appreciate how well it fills sparse areas while blending seamlessly. Reviewers frequently mention its long-lasting wear and the convenience of the built-in spoolie for grooming brows. Several customers express loyalty to the product, calling it their favorite brow pencil and noting its superiority over lower-priced alternatives. However, Target shoppers also report recurring quality control issues, including pencils that break easily, tips that fall out, and mechanisms that fail to twist up the product. Some users receive dried-out or defective items, leading to frustration with durability and product consistency. A few reviewers caution against purchasing from certain Target locations or third-party sellers due to concerns about receiving used or returned merchandise. Despite these drawbacks, many still find the formula and performance worth the premium price, especially when purchased during sales at Target.

3.6 Stars / Few verified reviews

Forum Icon

Forum Reviews

CUSTOMER REVIEWS FROM 1 FORUM


83
Logo of Reddit

Reddit users generally appreciate the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz for its natural-looking, precise application and suitable shade range, especially for those with light brown or red-auburn tones. Many praise its fine, slim design that allows for detailed brow definition, though some note issues with the packaging’s durability, such as the spoolie breaking or falling out. While the formula is often described as slightly waxy and less creamy compared to competitors, it delivers consistent results. Some users express frustration over its price and limited availability during sales, but overall, it remains a favored choice among both long-time users and those upgrading from other brands.

Many comments

Scales Icon

In-Depth Review

Highlights Icon

Highlights

  • •
    Applicator precision
    1mm ultra-fine tip for detail
  • •
    Retractable mechanism
    Twist-up design avoids sharpening
  • •
    Formula texture
    Wax-plus-pigment for smooth, buildable color
  • •
    Spoolie included
    Dual-ended brush for blending
  • •
    Shade range
    Available in 12 targeted shades
  • •
    Ethical labeling
    Marketed as cruelty-free and vegan
Considerations Icon

Considerations

  • •
    Packaging fragility
    Caps and plastic prone to cracking
  • •
    Lead detachment
    Reports of pencil lead falling out
  • •
    Product longevity
    Small size and fast depletion reported
  • •
    Value sensitivity
    Premium price prompts mixed opinions
  • •
    Wear inconsistency
    Longevity and smudge resistance vary
  • •
    Spoolie durability
    Spoolie can be small or detach

Anastasia Beverly Hills, a name synonymous with brow mastery, offers the Brow Wiz as an ultra-slim precision pencil designed to craft natural-looking eyebrows with professional finesse. Positioned at the premium end of the market, this product is ideal for users seeking detailed definition and effortless blending in one tool. Its standout feature is the 1mm retractable tip, allowing meticulous hair-like strokes that appeal to both novices and pros aiming for subtlety or drama. Complemented by a built-in spoolie brush and a broad palette of 12 carefully curated shades, it promises customization across diverse skin tones and hair colors. While celebrated for its rich wax-pigment formula delivering smooth application and vibrant pigmentation, some caution surrounds its delicate packaging. Whether you’re battling sparse brows or refining full arches, understanding these nuances will help you decide if this blend of artistry and convenience fits your routine—because flawless brows deserve nothing less than precision paired with practicality.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Breakability / Build Quality

While the pencil glides on smoothly, durability raises some eyebrows: reports highlight fragile plastic caps, frequent lead breakage, and occasional spoolie detachment issues that can frustrate daily use. The retractable mechanism itself works well but packaging materials sometimes falter under travel or storage stress. Despite these build quirks, many find the formula inside worth protecting carefully—a reminder that this product demands gentle handling to maintain its finesse over time.

Applicator Precision

Precision is king with the ultra-fine 1mm tip, delivering hair-like strokes that let users sculpt brows with meticulous control. This retractable design means no sharpening drama—just twist and go for flawless detail. The fine point excels at reaching sparse areas, making it a favorite for those craving natural definition without bulk. Experts and users alike praise its ability to mimic real brow hairs, ensuring each stroke blends seamlessly into existing texture. It’s precision perfected, especially for fans of subtlety who want every hair accounted for.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

Shade Range & Matchability

With an impressive palette spanning 12 shades—from Blonde through Granite—the product caters thoughtfully to cool and warm undertones alike. This breadth supports precise shade matching across diverse hair colors and skin tones, reducing guesswork during selection. Reviewers consistently note accurate color rendering that avoids unnatural hues common in other pencils; this nuanced range empowers both novices and pros seeking seamless integration into their beauty routines.

Formula Texture & Pigmentation

The wax-pigment blend strikes a satisfying balance between smooth application and rich color payoff; it deposits vibrant pigment with light pressure yet remains buildable for layering effects. This dry-wax formula ensures a matte finish free from greasiness or clumping while providing long-lasting wear in everyday conditions. Users appreciate how easily it adapts from soft fills to bolder looks without harsh lines—a versatile performance trait backed by expert approval.

Blendability & Spoolie Performance

The integrated spoolie brush earns kudos for smoothing out strokes effortlessly while adding dimension through blending; its dual-ended convenience saves steps in grooming routines. Although some mention the spoolie's size as slightly small compared to alternatives, most agree it performs well enough to achieve natural gradients when paired with careful application techniques—reinforcing how essential blending is for avoiding harsh edges in detailed brow work.

Conclusion

When precision meets polish, this pencil’s ultra-fine applicator crafts hairlike strokes that turn sparse brows into works of art. Yet, the allure dims slightly under scrutiny of its fragile build quality, where delicate casing invites breakage and frustration. The rich wax-pigment formula glides on with enviable pigmentation, while its broad shade range ensures nearly every complexion finds a match. Blendability shines through the handy spoolie, smoothing edges for a natural finish many users crave. Longevity holds up well in everyday wear but wavers against heavy sweat or oily skin challenges. This product suits those who prize detailed control and nuanced color over rugged durability—ideal for meticulous artists rather than rough-and-ready users. It stakes its claim as a sophisticated tool balancing finesse with thoughtful design, rewarding gentle hands with standout results worthy of serious brow aficionados seeking elevated expression without compromise.

Feature Scores Icon

Feature Scores

This reflects reviews and ratings from established critics, journalists, and users who have evaluated the item. Their opinions provide a comprehensive assessment.

Performance

Color Range

5/5

Shade Match Accuracy

4/5

Pigmentation

4/5

Longevity

4/5

Transfer Resistance

4/5

Water Resistance

3/5

Smudge Resistance

4/5

Blendability

4/5

Applicator Precision

5/5

Natural Appearance

5/5

Value

Price-to-Quality Ratio

4/5

Product Size Value

3/5

Refillable Options

TBD

Design

Packaging Design

3/5

Applicator Ergonomics

4/5

Shade Label Clarity

4/5

Health

Ingredient Safety

4/5

Hypoallergenic Formulation

4/5

Safety

Eye Irritation Risk

4/5

Regulatory Compliance

TBD

Sustainability

Recyclability

TBD

Cruelty-Free Certification

5/5

Experience Style

Ease of Use

5/5

Customization Options

4/5

Specifications Icon

Specifications

This section outlines the product's key facts, covering essential features, details, dimensions, materials, and any unique characteristics that define its functionality and usability.

Performance

Value

Design

Safety

Sustainability

Experience Style

Question Mark Icon

Frequently Asked Questions


5 Questions