Find Yours
The Scoreboard
Does this improve your life? Considers, health, habits, and environmental impact.
Benefits
Trade-Offs
Mineral oil, waxes and polymers create smooth, non-drying glossy finish—unlike plant-based glosses.
Mineral oil, paraffin reliance indicates heavy refining—diverges from plant-oil eco-leaders.
Emollients (diisostearyl malate, beeswax) lock in moisture, soothing dry or flaky lips.
Polyethylene and polybutene can contribute microplastic persistence in environment, unlike zero-plastic brands.
Balanced texture and doe-foot applicator reduce stickiness, improving comfort and everyday wear.
Red and lake colorants are flagged for allergy/toxicity; divergence from mineral-pigment leaders.
Extensive pigment and dye palette offers flattering shades across many skin tones.
Parfum and scent ingredients can provoke irritation or allergies for sensitive users.
Fragrance adds comforting pastry-like vanilla note, boosting mood during daily use.
Nano silica and aluminum salts raise consumer safety and eco-awareness issues in formulation.
Preservatives like phenoxyethanol and aluminum benzoate keep product microbially safe and stable.
Benefits
Mineral oil, waxes and polymers create smooth, non-drying glossy finish—unlike plant-based glosses.
Emollients (diisostearyl malate, beeswax) lock in moisture, soothing dry or flaky lips.
Balanced texture and doe-foot applicator reduce stickiness, improving comfort and everyday wear.
Extensive pigment and dye palette offers flattering shades across many skin tones.
Fragrance adds comforting pastry-like vanilla note, boosting mood during daily use.
Preservatives like phenoxyethanol and aluminum benzoate keep product microbially safe and stable.
Trade-Offs
Mineral oil, paraffin reliance indicates heavy refining—diverges from plant-oil eco-leaders.
Polyethylene and polybutene can contribute microplastic persistence in environment, unlike zero-plastic brands.
Red and lake colorants are flagged for allergy/toxicity; divergence from mineral-pigment leaders.
Parfum and scent ingredients can provoke irritation or allergies for sensitive users.
Nano silica and aluminum salts raise consumer safety and eco-awareness issues in formulation.
Ingredient Insights
Alternatives
Join the Circle
Where real meets deal
Know what's worth buying-and when.
Tips, special offers, and rewards for buying and sharing.
Publications
5 LEADING PUBLICATION REVIEWS
Kathleen Suico from Allure highlights NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss in Crème Brulee as a pleasantly surprising drugstore find that challenges her usual aversion to lip gloss. She praises its lightweight, non-sticky formula and the subtle, pastry-like scent that sets it apart from typical sugary glosses. The doe-foot applicator delivers just the right amount of product for an even, shimmer-free pale pink finish that feels moisturizing and comfortable throughout the day. Suico appreciates that the color wears off gracefully without patchiness or buildup, making reapplication easy and enjoyable rather than a hassle. While she remains loyal to lipsticks and tinted balms overall, this gloss has earned a permanent spot in her purse for days when she wants a fuss-free, flattering shine. Her review balances honest reservations with genuine enthusiasm, offering a nuanced perspective that elevates this affordable gloss beyond typical drugstore options.
Michelle Wong from Lab Muffin Beauty Science praises NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss for its natural, lightly tinted finish and moisturizing, balm-like qualities. Initially hesitant due to its sticky, syrupy texture, she was won over by its pleasant vanilla scent and comfortable wear, noting it layers well over matte lipsticks to combat dryness. The glosses come in a wide shade range, with Wong appreciating the thoughtful packaging and color coordination. However, she finds the texture somewhat sticky if applied thickly and suggests those seeking more pigment try the Intense Butter Glosses instead. The Intense line offers richer color and better staying power but requires careful application to avoid transfer and fading, especially on pigmented lips. Wong highlights some shade limitations and the need for reapplication after eating. Overall, she offers a balanced, detailed review with practical insights on wearability, shade performance, and product formulation, making it a helpful guide for potential buyers.
Kathleen Suico from Allure highlights NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss in Crème Brulee as a pleasantly surprising drugstore find that challenges her usual aversion to lip gloss. She praises its lightweight, non-sticky formula and the subtle, pastry-like scent that sets it apart from typical sugary glosses. The doe-foot applicator delivers just the right amount of product for an even, shimmer-free pale pink finish that feels moisturizing and comfortable throughout the day. Suico appreciates that the color wears off gracefully without patchiness or buildup, making reapplication easy and enjoyable rather than a hassle. While she remains loyal to lipsticks and tinted balms overall, this gloss has earned a permanent spot in her purse for days when she wants a fuss-free, flattering shine. Her review balances honest reservations with genuine enthusiasm, offering a nuanced perspective that elevates this affordable gloss beyond typical drugstore options.
Michelle Wong from Lab Muffin Beauty Science praises NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss for its natural, lightly tinted finish and moisturizing, balm-like qualities. Initially hesitant due to its sticky, syrupy texture, she was won over by its pleasant vanilla scent and comfortable wear, noting it layers well over matte lipsticks to combat dryness. The glosses come in a wide shade range, with Wong appreciating the thoughtful packaging and color coordination. However, she finds the texture somewhat sticky if applied thickly and suggests those seeking more pigment try the Intense Butter Glosses instead. The Intense line offers richer color and better staying power but requires careful application to avoid transfer and fading, especially on pigmented lips. Wong highlights some shade limitations and the need for reapplication after eating. Overall, she offers a balanced, detailed review with practical insights on wearability, shade performance, and product formulation, making it a helpful guide for potential buyers.
Kathleen Suico from Allure highlights NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss in Crème Brulee as a pleasantly surprising drugstore find that challenges her usual aversion to lip gloss. She praises its lightweight, non-sticky formula and the subtle, pastry-like scent that sets it apart from typical sugary glosses. The doe-foot applicator delivers just the right amount of product for an even, shimmer-free pale pink finish that feels moisturizing and comfortable throughout the day. Suico appreciates that the color wears off gracefully without patchiness or buildup, making reapplication easy and enjoyable rather than a hassle. While she remains loyal to lipsticks and tinted balms overall, this gloss has earned a permanent spot in her purse for days when she wants a fuss-free, flattering shine. Her review balances honest reservations with genuine enthusiasm, offering a nuanced perspective that elevates this affordable gloss beyond typical drugstore options.
Michelle Wong from Lab Muffin Beauty Science praises NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss for its natural, lightly tinted finish and moisturizing, balm-like qualities. Initially hesitant due to its sticky, syrupy texture, she was won over by its pleasant vanilla scent and comfortable wear, noting it layers well over matte lipsticks to combat dryness. The glosses come in a wide shade range, with Wong appreciating the thoughtful packaging and color coordination. However, she finds the texture somewhat sticky if applied thickly and suggests those seeking more pigment try the Intense Butter Glosses instead. The Intense line offers richer color and better staying power but requires careful application to avoid transfer and fading, especially on pigmented lips. Wong highlights some shade limitations and the need for reapplication after eating. Overall, she offers a balanced, detailed review with practical insights on wearability, shade performance, and product formulation, making it a helpful guide for potential buyers.
YouTube
31 LEADING EXPERT & INFLUENCER REVIEWS
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Andrea ReneeAndrea Renee enthusiastically swatches new and classic NYX Butter Gloss shades, praising Butterscotch and Spiked Toffee as her favorites for their muted, wearable tones and versatility with or without lip liners. She offers detailed color comparisons, notes subtle reformulations, and highlights the gloss’s sheer, buildable coverage and smooth, non-sticky finish.
EmJustLikeYouJen from EmJustLikeYou enthusiastically praises the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss collection for its buttery, non-sticky texture that smooths and moisturizes even wrinkly lips. She highlights the wide shade range, consistent quality, and flattering colors like Tiramisu and Creme Brulee, noting great value and 4–6 hour wear despite some lighter shades being less pigmented.
Social
5 INFLUENCER REVIEWS
The Lipstick LesbiansThe Lipstick Lesbians highlights NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss as an affordable, widely loved lip gloss with an impressive 4.6-star rating and extensive shade range. They appreciate its value for just $5 and praise its ability to deliver exactly the colors they seek, especially berry tones, while noting it’s not the absolute top-tier formula. Overall, The Lipstick Lesbians recommends Butter Gloss as a reliable, budget-friendly option for those wanting a satisfying, everyday lip product with plenty of shade choices. It’s positioned as a go-to for casual wearers who prioritize variety and affordability over luxury performance.
LaQueshiaLaQueshia highlights her genuine enthusiasm for NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss, praising its pigmentation, affordability, and wide shade range. She shares a detailed comparison between her favorite shade, Spiked Coffee, and the warmer Brownie Drip, noting both scents and colors with warmth and excitement. Her personal preference for pink tones is clear, yet she appreciates the versatility of Brownie Drip and other shades like Praline and Madeline. Overall, LaQueshia strongly recommends the Butter Gloss line, expressing a willingness to repurchase and explore more shades. Her review conveys authentic affection and thoughtful nuance, making it a confident endorsement for fans seeking richly pigmented, budget-friendly lip glosses.
The Lipstick LesbiansThe Lipstick Lesbians highlights NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss as an affordable, widely loved lip gloss with an impressive 4.6-star rating and extensive shade range. They appreciate its value for just $5 and praise its ability to deliver exactly the colors they seek, especially berry tones, while noting it’s not the absolute top-tier formula. Overall, The Lipstick Lesbians recommends Butter Gloss as a reliable, budget-friendly option for those wanting a satisfying, everyday lip product with plenty of shade choices. It’s positioned as a go-to for casual wearers who prioritize variety and affordability over luxury performance.
LaQueshiaLaQueshia highlights her genuine enthusiasm for NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss, praising its pigmentation, affordability, and wide shade range. She shares a detailed comparison between her favorite shade, Spiked Coffee, and the warmer Brownie Drip, noting both scents and colors with warmth and excitement. Her personal preference for pink tones is clear, yet she appreciates the versatility of Brownie Drip and other shades like Praline and Madeline. Overall, LaQueshia strongly recommends the Butter Gloss line, expressing a willingness to repurchase and explore more shades. Her review conveys authentic affection and thoughtful nuance, making it a confident endorsement for fans seeking richly pigmented, budget-friendly lip glosses.
The Lipstick LesbiansThe Lipstick Lesbians highlights NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss as an affordable, widely loved lip gloss with an impressive 4.6-star rating and extensive shade range. They appreciate its value for just $5 and praise its ability to deliver exactly the colors they seek, especially berry tones, while noting it’s not the absolute top-tier formula. Overall, The Lipstick Lesbians recommends Butter Gloss as a reliable, budget-friendly option for those wanting a satisfying, everyday lip product with plenty of shade choices. It’s positioned as a go-to for casual wearers who prioritize variety and affordability over luxury performance.
LaQueshiaLaQueshia highlights her genuine enthusiasm for NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss, praising its pigmentation, affordability, and wide shade range. She shares a detailed comparison between her favorite shade, Spiked Coffee, and the warmer Brownie Drip, noting both scents and colors with warmth and excitement. Her personal preference for pink tones is clear, yet she appreciates the versatility of Brownie Drip and other shades like Praline and Madeline. Overall, LaQueshia strongly recommends the Butter Gloss line, expressing a willingness to repurchase and explore more shades. Her review conveys authentic affection and thoughtful nuance, making it a confident endorsement for fans seeking richly pigmented, budget-friendly lip glosses.
Store Reviews
CUSTOMER REVIEWS FROM 3 STORES
Amazon users praise the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss for its creamy, buttery texture that glides on smoothly without any stickiness. Many highlight its beautiful, shiny finish that enhances lip color, with some applying it as a subtle topper or a full-coverage gloss. Reviewers appreciate how it moisturizes lips without drying them out, making it comfortable for extended wear. Several customers find the color payoff rich and true to the online images, though a few note discrepancies in shade accuracy and pigmentation, especially with deeper hues. Opinions on longevity vary—while some enjoy lasting shine, others mention the need for reapplication after a few hours. Unique insights include using the gloss to accentuate the cupid’s bow for a polished look and pairing it with lip liners to extend wear. Overall, Amazon reviewers consider this gloss a high-quality, affordable option that rivals pricier brands, combining great texture, shine, and moisturizing benefits.
4.5 Stars / Many verified reviews
Ulta Beauty reviewers consistently praise the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss for its creamy, non-sticky formula that glides on smoothly and feels comfortable on the lips. Users highlight its impressive pigmentation, noting that it delivers a rich color payoff that can be worn alone or layered over lipstick to enhance any look. Many appreciate the gloss’s pleasant, subtle vanilla or bakery-inspired scent, which adds to the enjoyable application experience without being overpowering. Reviewers across diverse skin tones find the extensive shade range accommodating, with several calling out shades like Creme Brulee, Maple Blondie, Ginger Snap, and Tiramisu as flattering and versatile for everyday wear. The gloss imparts a natural, glossy finish that plumps lips and adds shine without the heaviness or tackiness typical of many lip glosses. Users also mention that the gloss helps keep lips moisturized, making it a favored choice for those who dislike drying lip products. While the gloss does not offer long-lasting wear—requiring reapplication after eating or several hours of wear—customers accept this as standard for glosses and appreciate the affordable price point that encourages frequent touch-ups. Some reviewers note that the color appears lighter or more sheer on lips than in the tube or online images, which they often find appealing for a subtle, natural look but advise others to swatch when possible. A few mention slight stickiness or occasional patchiness, especially on dry lips, recommending exfoliation beforehand for best results. Overall, Ulta Beauty users celebrate NYX Butter Gloss as a high-quality, budget-friendly lip gloss that combines smooth texture, flattering pigmentation, and a delightful scent, making it a go-to product for both casual and polished makeup styles.
4.5 Stars / Many verified reviews
Amazon users praise the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss for its creamy, buttery texture that glides on smoothly without any stickiness. Many highlight its beautiful, shiny finish that enhances lip color, with some applying it as a subtle topper or a full-coverage gloss. Reviewers appreciate how it moisturizes lips without drying them out, making it comfortable for extended wear. Several customers find the color payoff rich and true to the online images, though a few note discrepancies in shade accuracy and pigmentation, especially with deeper hues. Opinions on longevity vary—while some enjoy lasting shine, others mention the need for reapplication after a few hours. Unique insights include using the gloss to accentuate the cupid’s bow for a polished look and pairing it with lip liners to extend wear. Overall, Amazon reviewers consider this gloss a high-quality, affordable option that rivals pricier brands, combining great texture, shine, and moisturizing benefits.
4.5 Stars / Many verified reviews
Ulta Beauty reviewers consistently praise the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss for its creamy, non-sticky formula that glides on smoothly and feels comfortable on the lips. Users highlight its impressive pigmentation, noting that it delivers a rich color payoff that can be worn alone or layered over lipstick to enhance any look. Many appreciate the gloss’s pleasant, subtle vanilla or bakery-inspired scent, which adds to the enjoyable application experience without being overpowering. Reviewers across diverse skin tones find the extensive shade range accommodating, with several calling out shades like Creme Brulee, Maple Blondie, Ginger Snap, and Tiramisu as flattering and versatile for everyday wear. The gloss imparts a natural, glossy finish that plumps lips and adds shine without the heaviness or tackiness typical of many lip glosses. Users also mention that the gloss helps keep lips moisturized, making it a favored choice for those who dislike drying lip products. While the gloss does not offer long-lasting wear—requiring reapplication after eating or several hours of wear—customers accept this as standard for glosses and appreciate the affordable price point that encourages frequent touch-ups. Some reviewers note that the color appears lighter or more sheer on lips than in the tube or online images, which they often find appealing for a subtle, natural look but advise others to swatch when possible. A few mention slight stickiness or occasional patchiness, especially on dry lips, recommending exfoliation beforehand for best results. Overall, Ulta Beauty users celebrate NYX Butter Gloss as a high-quality, budget-friendly lip gloss that combines smooth texture, flattering pigmentation, and a delightful scent, making it a go-to product for both casual and polished makeup styles.
4.5 Stars / Many verified reviews
Forum Reviews
CUSTOMER REVIEWS FROM 1 FORUM
Reddit users generally express positive sentiment toward the NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss, praising its long-lasting wear, excellent color payoff, and pleasant scent reminiscent of homemade cookies. Many appreciate the variety of shades and the product’s affordability, though some note concerns about packaging size and minor design inconsistencies, such as cap colors not matching the gloss shade. While experienced users highlight the gloss’s superior performance compared to others in their collection, some new shoppers express frustration with shade inconsistencies and pigmentation differences between batches. Overall, the gloss is well-liked for its quality and value, with critiques mostly focused on packaging and occasional color variation.
Some comments
In-Depth Review
Highlights
- •TextureCreamy, non-sticky application
- •Shade range42+ shades, Brown Sugar collection
- •Moisturizing effectHydrating; keeps lips soft
- •Glossy finishHigh-shine, visible gloss
- •ApplicatorSoft doe-foot wand
- •Cruelty-free certificationCompany highlights PETA-certified cruelty-free
Considerations
- •LongevityVariable wear; needs reapplication
- •Color consistencyUneven pigmentation across batches
- •Stickiness reportsOccasional sticky feel reported
- •Batch variationInconsistent color between purchases
- •Packaging issuesLabeling or pack errors noted
- •Fragrance sensitivityContains fragrance; may irritate
NYX Professional Makeup’s Butter Gloss is positioned as a beloved, budget-friendly staple in the lip gloss arena, catering to beauty enthusiasts seeking both comfort and style. Designed to deliver a buttery smooth texture that glides on effortlessly without stickiness, it appeals especially to those who dislike the heavy tack of traditional glosses. With an impressive palette boasting over 40 inclusive shades, including the Brown Sugar collection tailored for deeper skin tones, it offers versatility across looks and occasions. Users appreciate its balance between hydration—thanks to ingredients like mineral oil—and glossy shine that pops without overwhelming. While longevity can vary by shade and wear habits, layering options extend its appeal for long-lasting vibrancy. The soft doe-foot applicator rounds out this approachable yet effective formula aimed at daily users craving ease and elegance alike. For anyone navigating the lip gloss jungle, these features are worth a closer look before swiping on your next pout-perfecting pick.
Moisturizing Effect
More than just glossy shine, this product aims at softening lips via moisturizing agents like mineral oil and beeswax, promoting supple comfort throughout wear time. Users often describe their lips feeling hydrated—not dry—which elevates everyday appeal beyond mere cosmetics into functional care territory and backs up manufacturer claims of conditioning benefits combined with luscious sheen.
Longevity (Wear Time)
Expect moderate staying power; some reviewers enjoy hours-long wear through casual sipping while others reapply more frequently after meals due to fading pigment intensity. The product performs best when layered over lipstick or paired with liners for extended duration—a savvy tip echoed by experts who value adaptable formulas suited for quick touch-ups rather than marathon endurance runs.
Shade Range
With over 40 hues spanning from sheer nudes to rich browns, this gloss covers diverse tastes and complexions with its inclusive Brown Sugar collection standing out for medium to deep skin tones. Shades range from solid buttery finishes to sparkling blings, offering versatility whether you want subtle shimmer or bold color payoff. Experts note this variety allows seamless transition across occasions while satisfying broad aesthetic preferences — an admirable palette breadth rarely seen at this price point.
Texture Feel
Dive into the buttery smoothness of this gloss, where creamy glide meets a non-sticky formula that users rave about. The texture is designed to offer both softness and shine without weighing lips down or feeling tacky. This balance between plush hydration and light wear makes it an everyday essential for those craving comfort with flair. Brand claims align well here, delivering on the promise of a silky finish that’s as soothing as it is dazzling — truly a standout in lip gloss textures.
Stickiness (Tack)
The hallmark claim here is a non-sticky feel, which many find refreshing compared to typical gooey glosses. While most praise the lightweight slip that avoids lip hair snagging or uncomfortable buildup, some report occasional mild stickiness depending on shade choice or layering habits. This variability hints at formulation nuances but generally supports brand messaging focused on comfort and ease-of-wear—an attribute crucial for long-lasting daily use without annoyance.
Conclusion
Navigating the world of lip gloss can be slippery, but here’s what sticks about this one: its buttery texture delivers a smooth glide that sidesteps the dreaded tackiness. The expansive shade range, including thoughtful options for deeper tones, broadens its appeal beyond typical drugstore picks. While some users find the wear time pleasantly moderate, others may crave more staying power—layering is your friend here. The formula’s moisturizing effect keeps lips soft without heaviness, and the doe-foot applicator scores high marks for precision and ease. Yet occasional reports of slight stickiness hint at subtle formulation quirks. This gloss fits best with those seeking an everyday companion offering effortless shine and comfort rather than marathon endurance or bold pigment saturation. In sum, it balances charm with practicality—a polished choice that earns respect without demanding reverence.
Feature Scores
This reflects reviews and ratings from established critics, journalists, and users who have evaluated the item. Their opinions provide a comprehensive assessment.
Performance
Shine Intensity
5/5
Longevity
3/5
Value
Price Competitiveness
4/5
Size to Price Ratio
4/5
Design
Packaging Aesthetics
4/5
Applicator Design
4/5
Health
Non-Irritating Formula
4/5
Ingredient Transparency
4/5
Safety
Microbial Stability
4/5
Tamper Evidence
3/5
Sustainability
Recyclable Packaging
2/5
Sustainable Ingredient Sourcing
1/5
Experience Style
Shade Range
5/5
Texture Feel
5/5
Specifications
This section outlines the product's key facts, covering essential features, details, dimensions, materials, and any unique characteristics that define its functionality and usability.
Performance
Value
Design
Safety
Sustainability
Experience Style
Frequently Asked Questions
5 Questions
Also Consider
2 Options
