ASICS GEL-NYC

Sean Go is clearly positive about the ASICS GEL-NYC, praising its comfort, cushioning, support, and solid general-release construction. He compares its balanced underfoot feel and arch support favorably to the GEL-Kayano 14, making it a promising choice for long days on your feet. The true-to-size fit worked well for his slightly wide feet, though he recommends sizing up for especially wide feet. His main reservation is the Concrete/Oatmeal colorway, whose darker GEL-NYC stripes looked better on the shelf than on foot. Overall, he likes the model and remains interested in trying other colorways.

Chris is highly enthusiastic about the ASICS GEL-NYC, calling it one of the most comfortable sneakers he’s bought in years. He praises its gorgeous hybrid design, premium suede-and-mesh construction, breathable upper, stable platform, GEL cushioning, and dense Ortholite insole, which together make it lightweight, supportive, and exceptionally comfortable for everyday walking. He considers the $140 price worthwhile, especially compared with similar New Balance hybrids, and appreciates the strong colorway selection. With true-to-size fit and no meaningful complaints beyond its lifestyle—not performance-running—role, Chris gives the GEL-NYC an emphatic recommendation.

Josh Dominic is highly enthusiastic about the ASICS GEL-NYC, ranking it his favorite model overall. He praises its balanced cushioning—soft enough for all-day wear while remaining stable and supportive—and considers it among ASICS’ best-looking sneakers, especially in premium suede and leather colorways. He personally prefers a half-size up because the fit runs slightly narrow, particularly for wider feet. The newer GEL-NYC version 2 adds FF BLAST cushioning and feels noticeably softer. Overall, Josh sees it as an exceptionally stylish, comfortable lifestyle sneaker, though his top ranking is driven more by looks than performance.

Julian’s Reviews is highly positive about the ASICS GEL-NYC, calling it one of ASICS’ favorite releases. He praises its attractive layered design, quality materials, GEL cushioning, stability, flexibility, and overall comfort. This black-on-black version feels slightly more substantial and supportive thanks to thicker mesh and heavier overlays, though that also makes it snugger than previous pairs. He recommends true to size for narrow or average feet and at least a half-size up for wide feet. His only real hesitation is the £155 price, suggesting buyers wait for an inevitable sale.

Jon Wong is highly enthusiastic about the ASICS GEL-NYC, calling it an overdue, comfortable addition to his collection. He praises its soft GEL cushioning, supportive and stable platform, roomy build, retro styling, and true-to-size fit, especially for wider feet. He also appreciates its accessibility and discounted price, while acknowledging that the bulky “dad shoe” aesthetic may not suit everyone. His review is primarily an excited unboxing and first try-on rather than long-term testing, with limited discussion of durability or performance beyond walking.

Bryan feels strongly positive about the ASICS GEL-NYC, calling this Ivy/Smoke Grey colorway his favorite non-collab release. He loves the breathable big-hole mesh, soft suede construction, silver contrast panel, and especially the understated heel GEL embroidery. He compares its cushioning to the GEL-1130 but finds the NYC more stable and firm, recommending true-to-size unless you prefer extra room. While he acknowledges the Kayano 14, 1130, and 2160 receive more attention, he believes the GEL-NYC looks better on foot, works effortlessly as an everyday sneaker, and was unfairly overlooked.

Romy Morris is clearly excited about her first ASICS GEL-NYC purchase. She chose the white, cream, and beige colorway as a versatile neutral to replace her silver Nike P-6000s, calling it cute, wearable, and suitably dad-style. The chunky silhouette looks slightly large to her, though she plans to try it on before deciding. Getting the £144 trainers for £100 in the sale adds to her enthusiasm, and she offers to share the link.