Buyary Home Logo

All the Reviews in One Score

fairlife iconfairlife
Core Power Elite High Protein Shake

fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shake

89

BUYARY SCORE

Rich chocolate flavor and high protein content praised, with some concerns over sweeteners.

fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shake is a muscle-fueling powerhouse designed for fitness buffs and busy bees craving convenience. Its 42 grams of milk-based protein packs serious punch, delivering a smooth, creamy texture that wins praise from users and experts alike. The shake’s authentic chocolate flavor impresses most, though some note the presence of artificial sweeteners, sparking mixed feelings. Shelf-stable packaging adds practical appeal for on-the-go lifestyles. Priced at a premium, it balances cost with concentrated nutrition and taste satisfaction—key factors shaping its overall appeal in the crowded protein shake arena.

Gluten-Free
Travel-Ready
Mobile-Ready
Long-Lasting
Ask Ari IconAskAri
Large Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image
Product Image

Find Yours

Answer a few questions to find your best matches.

Product recommendation preview
Numbered List Icon

The Scoreboard

Does this actually make your everyday life better? Considers health, habits, and environmental impact over time.

86

FIT

87

EXPERTS

92

USERS

86

VALUE

Benefits

💪

42g protein boost

Delivers 42 grams protein per bottle—far higher than typical ready-to-drink options.

🥛

Slow-release protein

Casein-dominant ultra‑filtered milk gives steady amino acids, unlike fast-acting whey powders.

🩺

Lactose-friendly formula

Contains lactase and ultra‑filtration—easier digestion for lactose-sensitive people, fewer cramps.

☀️

Bone-support vitamins

Added vitamin D, A and 900mg calcium support bone health and nutritional gaps.

🥤

Low added sugar

Ultra‑filtration plus zero added sugars helps calorie control while keeping pleasant chocolate flavor.

Trade-Offs

🧪

Artificial sweetener mix

Sucralose and acesulfame presence may affect gut microbiome and cause chemical aftertaste.

⚠️

Stabilizer digestive concern

Carrageenan used for smoothness has consumer-reported digestive irritation in some sensitive individuals.

🍫

Processed cocoa loss

Alkalized cocoa reduces native flavonoids—less antioxidant benefit than natural cocoa alternatives.

🐄

Dairy carbon footprint

Milk sourcing plus ultra‑filtration and large distribution increase greenhouse gases versus plant alternatives.

🏭

Packaging footprint

Single‑use bottle and Coca‑Cola scale mean plastic waste and transport emissions accumulate.

Nutrition Facts

1 servings per container

Serving size1 bottle (414 ml)

Amount per serving

Calories230
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 3.5g4%
Saturated Fat 2g10%
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 35mg12%
Sodium 260mg11%
Total Carbohydrate 9g3%
Dietary Fiber 2g7%
Total Sugars 7g
Added Sugars 0g0%
Protein 42g84%
Vitamin D 10mcg50%
Calcium 900mg70%
Iron 1.6mg8%
Potassium 700mg15%
Vitamin A 240mcg25%

* The % Daily Value (DV) tells you how much a nutrient in a serving of food contributes to a daily diet. 2,000 calories a day is used for general nutrition advice.

Gluten-Free

Ingredients

Filtered Lowfat Grade A MilkAlkalized CocoaNatural FlavorsSaltAcesulfame PotassiumCarrageenanMonk Fruit Juice ConcentrateCellulose GelCellulose GumStevia Leaf ExtractSucraloseLactase EnzymeVitamin A PalmitateVitamin D3

Alternatives

Fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shake delivers concentrated, fast-postworkout dairy protein and fortified vitamins, preserving convenient high-BCAA recovery but trading ingredient purity and a higher dairy environmental footprint due to processing and artificial sweeteners. Consider pea-protein recovery shakes or soy-protein recovery shakes as lower-impact, plant-based options that preserve protein focus while trading some dairy-derived bioavailability.
Document Icon

Publications

3 LEADING PUBLICATION REVIEWS


85

Logo of Ultimate Meal Plans

Joel Runyon from Ultimate Meal Plans highlights the fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shake as a convenient, shelf-stable option that effectively supports aggressive protein goals with its impressive 42g protein content. He praises the vanilla flavor as the standout, noting its smooth taste and lack of clumping, while chocolate is a solid alternative and fruit flavors like strawberry-banana are less favored due to artificial taste. The review appreciates fairlife’s ultra-filtration process that reduces sugar and lactose, delivering a cleaner ingredient profile compared to typical gas station options, though it flags the presence of sucralose and carrageenan as minor drawbacks. Runyon also expresses mild reservations about the protein blend’s high casein-to-whey ratio but considers this manageable. He values the brand’s wide availability, crediting Coca-Cola’s distribution for making a healthier protein shake accessible beyond niche markets. Overall, the tone is positive and practical, framing the product as a reliable, tasty, and efficient protein source for on-the-go consumers.

By Joel Runyon
December 6, 2024

92

Logo of Cheat Day Design

Matt assesses Fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shakes as some of the best ready-to-drink protein shakes available, praising their smooth, milk-like consistency and impressive protein content—42 grams per Elite shake—setting them apart from many competitors. He highlights the Elite versions for their intensified flavors and higher protein, especially vanilla and chocolate, which he finds delicious and versatile enough to use even as milk for cereal. However, he expresses disappointment with the strawberry banana flavor, finding it subtle and misleadingly labeled, and notes the limited flavor variety overall. While the shakes are pricier than some alternatives, their lactose-free formulation and enjoyable taste make them a standout choice. Matt’s enthusiasm is clear, particularly for the Elite line, which he calls a “no-brainer” for protein shake fans seeking both nutrition and flavor without the typical protein aftertaste.

By Matt

85

Logo of Ultimate Meal Plans

Joel Runyon from Ultimate Meal Plans highlights the fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shake as a convenient, shelf-stable option that effectively supports aggressive protein goals with its impressive 42g protein content. He praises the vanilla flavor as the standout, noting its smooth taste and lack of clumping, while chocolate is a solid alternative and fruit flavors like strawberry-banana are less favored due to artificial taste. The review appreciates fairlife’s ultra-filtration process that reduces sugar and lactose, delivering a cleaner ingredient profile compared to typical gas station options, though it flags the presence of sucralose and carrageenan as minor drawbacks. Runyon also expresses mild reservations about the protein blend’s high casein-to-whey ratio but considers this manageable. He values the brand’s wide availability, crediting Coca-Cola’s distribution for making a healthier protein shake accessible beyond niche markets. Overall, the tone is positive and practical, framing the product as a reliable, tasty, and efficient protein source for on-the-go consumers.

By Joel Runyon
December 6, 2024

92

Logo of Cheat Day Design

Matt assesses Fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shakes as some of the best ready-to-drink protein shakes available, praising their smooth, milk-like consistency and impressive protein content—42 grams per Elite shake—setting them apart from many competitors. He highlights the Elite versions for their intensified flavors and higher protein, especially vanilla and chocolate, which he finds delicious and versatile enough to use even as milk for cereal. However, he expresses disappointment with the strawberry banana flavor, finding it subtle and misleadingly labeled, and notes the limited flavor variety overall. While the shakes are pricier than some alternatives, their lactose-free formulation and enjoyable taste make them a standout choice. Matt’s enthusiasm is clear, particularly for the Elite line, which he calls a “no-brainer” for protein shake fans seeking both nutrition and flavor without the typical protein aftertaste.

By Matt
Play TV Icon

YouTube

5 LEADING EXPERT & INFLUENCER REVIEWS


87

Youtube IconDr Todd Sullivan

Dr Todd Sullivan praises Fairlife Core Power Elite for its lactose-free, high-protein formula (42g per shake) that supports weight loss and muscle recovery without digestive issues. He highlights its convenience and taste but notes the higher price compared to competitors. Overall, he strongly recommends it for those needing effective, easy protein intake.

March 6, 2024

88

Youtube IconNicole Hoskens

Nicole Hoskens praises fairlife Core Power Elite for its high protein content (42g) and smooth, chocolate-milk-like taste, ideal for post-workout recovery. She notes the 42g version is thinner and slightly more “protein shake” tasting than the 26g. While she appreciates the nutrition and flavor, she suggests pairing it with carbs for optimal refueling.

May 27, 2022

87

Youtube IconDr Todd Sullivan

Dr Todd Sullivan praises Fairlife Core Power Elite for its lactose-free, high-protein formula (42g per shake) that supports weight loss and muscle recovery without digestive issues. He highlights its convenience and taste but notes the higher price compared to competitors. Overall, he strongly recommends it for those needing effective, easy protein intake.

March 6, 2024

88

Youtube IconNicole Hoskens

Nicole Hoskens praises fairlife Core Power Elite for its high protein content (42g) and smooth, chocolate-milk-like taste, ideal for post-workout recovery. She notes the 42g version is thinner and slightly more “protein shake” tasting than the 26g. While she appreciates the nutrition and flavor, she suggests pairing it with carbs for optimal refueling.

May 27, 2022

87

Youtube IconDr Todd Sullivan

Dr Todd Sullivan praises Fairlife Core Power Elite for its lactose-free, high-protein formula (42g per shake) that supports weight loss and muscle recovery without digestive issues. He highlights its convenience and taste but notes the higher price compared to competitors. Overall, he strongly recommends it for those needing effective, easy protein intake.

March 6, 2024

88

Youtube IconNicole Hoskens

Nicole Hoskens praises fairlife Core Power Elite for its high protein content (42g) and smooth, chocolate-milk-like taste, ideal for post-workout recovery. She notes the 42g version is thinner and slightly more “protein shake” tasting than the 26g. While she appreciates the nutrition and flavor, she suggests pairing it with carbs for optimal refueling.

May 27, 2022
Store Bag Icon

Store Reviews

CUSTOMER REVIEWS FROM 2 STORES


93

Logo of Amazon

Amazon users consistently praise the fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shake for its rich, smooth chocolate flavor that closely resembles indulgent chocolate milk without being overly sweet or chalky. Many highlight the impressive 42 grams of protein per 14-ounce bottle, which helps them easily meet daily protein goals, supports post-workout recovery, and serves as a convenient meal replacement. Reviewers appreciate the shake’s creamy texture and low sugar content, noting it digests well even for those sensitive to lactose. Several customers mention mixing it into coffee for a mocha-like experience, adding a unique twist to their routine. While some find the price steep compared to bulk powders or other ready-to-drink options, others justify the cost by valuing the taste, convenience, and high protein density. Additionally, users acknowledge the inclusion of artificial sweeteners like stevia and sucralose but generally feel these do not overpower the flavor or cause digestive issues. Overall, Amazon reviewers regard this shake as a tasty, effective, and practical protein source that stands out in both flavor and nutritional content.

4.6 Stars / Many verified reviews

87

Logo of Target

Users on Target praise the fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shake for its rich, smooth chocolate milk flavor and impressive protein content, often highlighting its ability to deliver 42 grams of protein without the chalky or artificial aftertaste common in other shakes. Many appreciate that it tastes like a regular chocolate milkshake, making it a favorite for post-workout recovery or a convenient meal replacement. Reviewers also note the shake’s low fat and cholesterol levels despite being milk-based, and some enjoy adding it to coffee or espresso for a filling breakfast option. Several customers value its lactose-free quality, likely due to ultra-filtration, which broadens its appeal. On the other hand, some users express strong dislike for the inclusion of multiple artificial sweeteners like stevia and sucralose, reporting an overpowering chemical taste. A few raise concerns about carrageenan and its potential digestive effects. While most find the texture pleasantly smooth and not overly thick, a minority find it too thick or chalky. Overall, Target reviewers emphasize the shake’s superior taste and nutritional profile compared to other ready-to-drink protein options, making it a standout choice for those seeking both flavor and high protein in a convenient format.

4.4 Stars / Few verified reviews

Forum Icon

Forum Reviews

CUSTOMER REVIEWS FROM 1 FORUM


82

Logo of Reddit

Reddit users generally express a positive sentiment toward the Fairlife Core Power Elite High Protein Shake, praising its taste, especially the 30-gram protein option in the white bottle, which many consider the best premade protein shake available. The shake is appreciated for its high protein content, lactose-free formulation, and satisfying flavor that resembles chocolate milk. However, some users critique the 42-gram protein version for being overly sweet, expensive, and less palatable, with occasional mentions of an off or chemical taste. Overall, new shoppers and upgraders alike value the product’s performance and flavor, though price and taste preferences vary.

Many comments

Scales Icon

In-Depth Review

Highlights Icon

Highlights

  • High protein content
    42 g per 14 fl oz
  • Creamy texture
    Smooth, non-gritty mouthfeel
  • Lactose-free formulation
    Treated with lactase enzyme
  • Milk-based protein source
    Ultra-filtered milk concentrate
  • Ready-to-drink convenience
    Shelf-stable until opening
  • Authentic chocolate flavor
    Milkshake-like chocolate profile
Considerations Icon

Considerations

  • Artificial sweeteners
    Contains sucralose and acesulfame K
  • Higher cost
    Above many comparable bottles
  • Additive concerns
    Includes carrageenan and stabilizers
  • Flavor inconsistency
    Some batches/flavors taste off
  • Milk allergen
    Contains milk proteins despite lactose-free
  • Calorie density
    ~230 kcal per bottle

Fairlife’s Core Power Elite High Protein Shake stakes its claim as a potent recovery companion, boasting an impressive 42 grams of protein per 14-ounce bottle sourced from ultra-filtered milk for complete amino acid delivery. Designed with athletes and busy professionals in mind, this shake blends convenience with nutrition, offering a smooth, creamy texture that avoids the gritty pitfalls common in protein drinks. The chocolate flavor delivers an authentic milkshake experience while remaining shelf-stable for up to nine months—perfect for on-the-go lifestyles. Enhanced with essential micronutrients like calcium and vitamin D, it also caters to those sensitive to lactose through specialized enzymatic processing. For anyone balancing intense workouts or hectic schedules seeking both taste and muscle fuel, these features set the product apart in a crowded market. Ready your palate and performance; what follows unpacks how well it truly performs where it counts most.

Product Image

Taste / Flavor Accuracy

Flavor fidelity matters when you want indulgence without compromise—this chocolate variant nails rich cocoa notes reminiscent of real milkshakes while steering clear of artificial aftertastes found elsewhere. The vanilla option earns kudos for creaminess but strawberry flavors divide opinion due to sweetener profiles like sucralose and acesulfame potassium which some find slightly chemical-tasting. This balance between authentic taste and artificial sweeteners keeps fans loyal yet cautious.

Protein Quantity

When it comes to muscle fuel, this shake packs a serious punch with 42 grams of protein per 14 oz bottle, designed for optimal post-workout recovery. Sourced from ultra-filtered milk rather than powders, it delivers a complete amino acid profile that supports repair and satiety. Reviewers consistently praise the generous protein dose as ideal for those seeking maximum impact without multiple servings. The high concentration sets it apart in the ready-to-drink category, making it a true heavyweight contender among shakes.

Shelf Stability / Storage

The convenience factor skyrockets thanks to shelf stability allowing storage at room temperature up to nine months before opening—a boon for travelers and gym bags alike who need reliable nutrition anytime without refrigeration hassle. This aseptic packaging method ensures freshness without preservatives until first sip while supporting flexible purchase patterns through bulk multipacks or singles—ideal for modern active lifestyles craving both performance and practicality.

Texture / Mouthfeel

Texture can make or break your shake experience, and here it's all about smooth sailing. Thanks to ingredients like carrageenan (seaweed-derived stabilizer), this product boasts a creamy consistency that avoids grit or chalkiness common in powdered alternatives. Users note its silky mouthfeel enhances drinkability during busy days or after intense workouts. While some report occasional sliminess tied to thickening agents, overall the texture is crafted for easy enjoyment on-the-go.

Conclusion

Peeling back the layers reveals a shake that punches above its weight with a hefty 42 grams of protein and a lactose-free formula tailored for sensitive stomachs. Its smooth, creamy texture sidesteps gritty pitfalls, while the authentic chocolate flavor earns nods for richness balanced against occasional sweetener quirks. The boon of nine-month shelf stability adds rare convenience in a crowded market where freshness often demands refrigeration. Enhanced by key micronutrients like calcium and vitamin D, it fuels more than just muscles—offering thoughtful nutritional breadth. While not designed for those seeking minimal additives or budget options, this shake shines as an efficient muscle refueler and meal stand-in. For athletes or busy movers craving both taste and substance without lactose worries, it strikes a compelling chord—a blend that’s as practical as it is palatable.

Feature Scores Icon

Feature Scores

This reflects reviews and ratings from established critics, journalists, and users who have evaluated the item. Their opinions provide a comprehensive assessment.

Performance

Protein Quality

5/5

Protein Quantity Per Serving

5/5

Mixability

5/5

Taste Profile

4/5

Texture Mouthfeel

5/5

Satiety

4/5

Value

Price Per Serving

4/5

Serving Size Value

4/5

Availability Retail Access

5/5

Design

Packaging Aesthetics

4/5

Bottle Ergonomics

4/5

Label Readability

4/5

Health

Added Sugars

4/5

Allergen Management

4/5

Micronutrient Fortification

4/5

Ingredient Transparency

4/5

Safety

Contaminant Testing

3/5

Shelf Stability

5/5

Regulatory Compliance

4/5

Sustainability

Packaging Recyclability

3/5

Ingredient Sourcing Sustainability

3/5

Production Emissions

2/5

Waste Reduction Initiatives

2/5

Experience Style

Convenience

5/5

Customization Options

2/5

Flavor Variety

4/5

Serving Format Options

4/5

Nutrition Guidance

3/5

Specifications Icon

Specifications

This section outlines the product's key facts, covering essential features, details, dimensions, materials, and any unique characteristics that define its functionality and usability.

Performance

Value

Design

Safety

Experience Style

Question Mark Icon

Frequently Asked Questions


7 Questions