Buyary Home Logo

All the Reviews in One Score

AskAri
Nissan Maxima (2023)

Nissan Maxima (2023)

76
BUYARY SCORE

300-hp V6 power, upscale comfort, and standout style, with CVT compromises.

The 2023 Nissan Maxima is a stylish last-of-its-kind sedan for drivers who want effortless highway power and a more polished alternative to ordinary family transportation. Its 300-hp naturally aspirated V6, quiet cabin, comfortable leather seats, and distinctive design support Nissan’s near-luxury pitch, while reviewers especially enjoy the SR’s composed ride and sharper attitude. But the “four-door sports car” claim overreaches: the CVT can feel disconnected, front-wheel drive limits enthusiasm, and rear space trails cheaper rivals. At roughly $38,000 to $45,000 new, it offers genuine comfort and character, though fuel costs, dated technology, and reported CVT repairs complicate the value. Its overall appeal rests on balancing V6 enjoyment and upscale comfort against practicality and ownership risk.

Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
Nissan Maxima (2023)
AskAri

Find Yours

Step 011 of 4 questions

What is your primary use for a gas-powered sedan or compact?

Answer to find your best matches.

The Scoreboard

Does this improve your life? Considers, health, habits, and environmental impact.

82
FIT
79
EXPERTS
65
USERS
67
VALUE

Benefits

🛋️
Quiet, comfortable cabin

A calm cabin and supportive front seats make commuting and long drives easier.

300-hp passing power

The smooth V6 makes merging, passing, and highway driving feel effortless.

Upscale everyday cabin

Leather, quietness, navigation, and strong audio make ordinary errands feel noticeably more comfortable.

🛡️
Confidence-building safety

Standard driver aids quietly help with blind spots, reversing, and sudden traffic hazards.

🎨
Standout sedan styling

Distinctive looks help you feel like you chose something more special than routine transportation.

Trade-Offs

🔄
CVT feels disconnected

Acceleration can sound busy without feeling natural, making merges less satisfying and harder to judge.

🧍
Cramped back seat

Taller passengers may rub knees or lose headroom, making family rides less comfortable.

📱
Older phone experience

Wired phone connection and dated screens add cable clutter and extra steps during everyday driving.

More frequent refueling

Compared with efficient four-cylinder sedans, ordinary commutes require more frequent trips to the pump.

Nissan Maxima (2023)

Alternatives

The 2023 Nissan Maxima delivers effortless highway pace and a genuinely upscale cabin while its 300-hp V6 gives family-sedan duties extra spark. Its front-wheel-drive layout and CVT can feel less engaging on curvy roads, though, so efficiency-minded drivers might prefer hybrid midsize sedans for better fuel economy, while shoppers prioritizing all-weather traction and sharper handling may lean toward AWD sport sedans instead.
Circle

Join the Circle

Where real meets deal

Know what's worth buying-and when.
Tips, special offers, and rewards for buying and sharing.

Document Icon

Publications

2 LEADING PUBLICATION REVIEWS


76
Logo of MotorTrend

MotorTrend gives the 2023 Nissan Maxima a measured thumbs-up, admiring its speed and upscale feel while questioning its value. Its 300-hp V6 makes the Maxima satisfyingly quick, and the sharp handling and especially rich Platinum cabin help it feel more premium than a Nissan typically might. Safety equipment is excellent, with top crash-test marks and a generous suite of standard driver aids. Still, the Maxima occupies an awkward middle ground: it costs nearly $40,000, yet offers less rear legroom and cargo space than cheaper alternatives such as the Altima, Accord, and Camry. Its heavy steering, front-wheel-drive layout, CVT, mediocre fuel economy, and only mildly sporty character further weaken the “four-door sports car” pitch. MotorTrend’s preferred Platinum trim is attractive and comfortable, but the overall package feels hard to justify unless luxury appointments matter more than practicality or efficiency.

By Willis Kuelthau

78
Logo of Kelley Blue Book

Kelley Blue Book views the 2023 Nissan Maxima as a polished, genuinely enjoyable sedan with sensible compromises. Its energetic 300-horsepower V6, composed ride, quiet cabin, comfortable front seats, and above-average materials give it an appealing near-luxury character without making it intimidating to drive. The front-wheel-drive layout sacrifices some sportiness, but it remains easy to manage, and the SR adds sharper styling and paddle shifters for extra engagement. The main frustrations are the CVT’s lack of natural responsiveness, steering that could provide more feedback, and rear-seat and trunk space that trail the smaller Altima. Its technology is functional rather than cutting-edge, while premium fuel raises running costs. Overall, KBB presents the Maxima as a distinctive, well-rounded choice for buyers who value V6 performance and comfort, even if its impending discontinuation and limited practicality make it less compelling than some rivals.

By Colin Ryan

January 30, 2025Visit Source →
Play TV Icon

YouTube

10 LEADING EXPERT & INFLUENCER REVIEWS


76
Youtube IconTheTopher

TheTopher is moderately positive about the 2023 Nissan Maxima, but its sporty promise leaves him unconvinced. He enjoys the naturally aspirated 300-hp V6, attractive styling, comfortable cabin, strong Bose audio, useful space, and surprisingly agile SR chassis. The heated-and-cooled seat controls, physical controls, adaptive cruise, and standard spare tire also add character. Still, inconsistent hydroelectric steering, wet-weather understeer, modest tire grip, dated infotainment, stiff ride, and especially the CVT undermine the experience. He views it as a pleasant daily sedan with genuine strengths, yet believes Nissan should have given this final-year Maxima a proper automatic transmission and sharper enthusiast focus.

May 25, 2024
78
Youtube IconRaiti's Rides

Joe Raiti is warmly impressed by the 2023 Nissan Maxima, though he stops short of calling it a true sports sedan. He praises its distinctive styling, upscale Platinum cabin, comfortable heated and ventilated seats, roomy rear quarters, useful trunk, and smooth 300-hp naturally aspirated V6. However, the CVT feels disconnected, steering feedback is vague, and front-wheel drive makes it less nimble and engaging than the Genesis G70 or Kia Stinger GT. His larger takeaway is wistful: with a rear-wheel-drive platform and better transmission, the Maxima could have been a standout. As it stands, it’s a comfortable, unique, compelling final-year sedan rather than the four-door sports car Nissan claims.

December 24, 2022
76
Youtube IconTheTopher

TheTopher is moderately positive about the 2023 Nissan Maxima, but its sporty promise leaves him unconvinced. He enjoys the naturally aspirated 300-hp V6, attractive styling, comfortable cabin, strong Bose audio, useful space, and surprisingly agile SR chassis. The heated-and-cooled seat controls, physical controls, adaptive cruise, and standard spare tire also add character. Still, inconsistent hydroelectric steering, wet-weather understeer, modest tire grip, dated infotainment, stiff ride, and especially the CVT undermine the experience. He views it as a pleasant daily sedan with genuine strengths, yet believes Nissan should have given this final-year Maxima a proper automatic transmission and sharper enthusiast focus.

May 25, 2024
78
Youtube IconRaiti's Rides

Joe Raiti is warmly impressed by the 2023 Nissan Maxima, though he stops short of calling it a true sports sedan. He praises its distinctive styling, upscale Platinum cabin, comfortable heated and ventilated seats, roomy rear quarters, useful trunk, and smooth 300-hp naturally aspirated V6. However, the CVT feels disconnected, steering feedback is vague, and front-wheel drive makes it less nimble and engaging than the Genesis G70 or Kia Stinger GT. His larger takeaway is wistful: with a rear-wheel-drive platform and better transmission, the Maxima could have been a standout. As it stands, it’s a comfortable, unique, compelling final-year sedan rather than the four-door sports car Nissan claims.

December 24, 2022
76
Youtube IconTheTopher

TheTopher is moderately positive about the 2023 Nissan Maxima, but its sporty promise leaves him unconvinced. He enjoys the naturally aspirated 300-hp V6, attractive styling, comfortable cabin, strong Bose audio, useful space, and surprisingly agile SR chassis. The heated-and-cooled seat controls, physical controls, adaptive cruise, and standard spare tire also add character. Still, inconsistent hydroelectric steering, wet-weather understeer, modest tire grip, dated infotainment, stiff ride, and especially the CVT undermine the experience. He views it as a pleasant daily sedan with genuine strengths, yet believes Nissan should have given this final-year Maxima a proper automatic transmission and sharper enthusiast focus.

May 25, 2024
78
Youtube IconRaiti's Rides

Joe Raiti is warmly impressed by the 2023 Nissan Maxima, though he stops short of calling it a true sports sedan. He praises its distinctive styling, upscale Platinum cabin, comfortable heated and ventilated seats, roomy rear quarters, useful trunk, and smooth 300-hp naturally aspirated V6. However, the CVT feels disconnected, steering feedback is vague, and front-wheel drive makes it less nimble and engaging than the Genesis G70 or Kia Stinger GT. His larger takeaway is wistful: with a rear-wheel-drive platform and better transmission, the Maxima could have been a standout. As it stands, it’s a comfortable, unique, compelling final-year sedan rather than the four-door sports car Nissan claims.

December 24, 2022
76
Youtube IconTheTopher

TheTopher is moderately positive about the 2023 Nissan Maxima, but its sporty promise leaves him unconvinced. He enjoys the naturally aspirated 300-hp V6, attractive styling, comfortable cabin, strong Bose audio, useful space, and surprisingly agile SR chassis. The heated-and-cooled seat controls, physical controls, adaptive cruise, and standard spare tire also add character. Still, inconsistent hydroelectric steering, wet-weather understeer, modest tire grip, dated infotainment, stiff ride, and especially the CVT undermine the experience. He views it as a pleasant daily sedan with genuine strengths, yet believes Nissan should have given this final-year Maxima a proper automatic transmission and sharper enthusiast focus.

May 25, 2024
78
Youtube IconRaiti's Rides

Joe Raiti is warmly impressed by the 2023 Nissan Maxima, though he stops short of calling it a true sports sedan. He praises its distinctive styling, upscale Platinum cabin, comfortable heated and ventilated seats, roomy rear quarters, useful trunk, and smooth 300-hp naturally aspirated V6. However, the CVT feels disconnected, steering feedback is vague, and front-wheel drive makes it less nimble and engaging than the Genesis G70 or Kia Stinger GT. His larger takeaway is wistful: with a rear-wheel-drive platform and better transmission, the Maxima could have been a standout. As it stands, it’s a comfortable, unique, compelling final-year sedan rather than the four-door sports car Nissan claims.

December 24, 2022
76
Youtube IconTheTopher

TheTopher is moderately positive about the 2023 Nissan Maxima, but its sporty promise leaves him unconvinced. He enjoys the naturally aspirated 300-hp V6, attractive styling, comfortable cabin, strong Bose audio, useful space, and surprisingly agile SR chassis. The heated-and-cooled seat controls, physical controls, adaptive cruise, and standard spare tire also add character. Still, inconsistent hydroelectric steering, wet-weather understeer, modest tire grip, dated infotainment, stiff ride, and especially the CVT undermine the experience. He views it as a pleasant daily sedan with genuine strengths, yet believes Nissan should have given this final-year Maxima a proper automatic transmission and sharper enthusiast focus.

May 25, 2024
78
Youtube IconRaiti's Rides

Joe Raiti is warmly impressed by the 2023 Nissan Maxima, though he stops short of calling it a true sports sedan. He praises its distinctive styling, upscale Platinum cabin, comfortable heated and ventilated seats, roomy rear quarters, useful trunk, and smooth 300-hp naturally aspirated V6. However, the CVT feels disconnected, steering feedback is vague, and front-wheel drive makes it less nimble and engaging than the Genesis G70 or Kia Stinger GT. His larger takeaway is wistful: with a rear-wheel-drive platform and better transmission, the Maxima could have been a standout. As it stands, it’s a comfortable, unique, compelling final-year sedan rather than the four-door sports car Nissan claims.

December 24, 2022

Social

1 INFLUENCER REVIEW


88
TikTok IconElegantJerk

ElegantJerk is highly enthusiastic about the 2023 Nissan Maxima, calling it a vehicle worth buying again. They relay that one Maxima saved its owner’s life in a head-on collision, reinforcing a strong impression of safety and durability. The main caveat is availability rather than performance: Nissan planned to discontinue the Maxima in June 2023, making that model year the final opportunity to purchase a new one. Overall, the tone is warm and strongly recommendatory, though the safety claim is anecdotal rather than supported by testing details.

January 18, 2023
Forum Icon

Forum Reviews

CUSTOMER REVIEWS FROM 1 FORUM


65
Logo of Reddit

Redditors generally like the 2023 Nissan Maxima, but many remain wary of its CVT reliability. It earns praise for its strong, smooth V6, comfortable ride, quiet cabin, sharp styling, upscale interior, and confident highway handling. Owners often report dependable service when CVT fluid is changed regularly, though multiple failures around 80,000–100,000 miles—and occasional repair bills near $6,000—keep reliability opinions divided. The discontinued model also raises depreciation concerns, especially at prices approaching Lexus or Acura territory. Enthusiasts upgrading from older Maximas love the newer SR’s appearance and feel, while shoppers are more likely to skip it because of the transmission risk and lack of a conventional automatic.

Many comments

Scales Icon

In-Depth Review

Highlights Icon

Highlights

  • Strong V6 acceleration
    Smooth 300-hp power aids passing.
  • Composed road manners
    Sport-tuned suspension balances comfort and control.
  • Upscale front cabin
    Leather seating and quietness feel near-luxury.
  • Distinctive sedan styling
    Swoopy design stands apart from rivals.
Considerations Icon

Considerations

  • CVT ownership risk
    Feel varies, with reported costly failures.
  • Limited sportiness
    Front-wheel drive and vague steering reduce engagement.
  • Restricted rear space
    Taller passengers may find seating cramped.
  • Higher fuel costs
    V6 efficiency trails four-cylinder and hybrid rivals.

Nissan’s final Maxima is a polished alternative to ordinary family sedans, pairing 300-hp V6 power with a more upscale, sport-minded personality. It is designed for commuters and highway travelers who want effortless passing, a quiet cabin, and distinctive styling without stepping fully into luxury-car pricing. Compared with an Altima, Accord, or Camry, it feels richer and quicker, though its front-wheel-drive layout and Xtronic CVT make the sporty promise more complicated. The following sections examine how its sport-tuned suspension, front-seat comfort, and cabin materials translate to daily driving, along with whether the rear seat and trunk deliver enough practicality. Fuel use and long-term transmission concerns also deserve close attention, especially for budget-conscious buyers. In short, the Maxima offers muscle and polish in an increasingly rare sedan package—now let’s see where that charm earns its keep.

Nissan Maxima (2023)

CVT Driving Feel

The Xtronic transmission is the Maxima’s most persistent dynamic compromise. It keeps the V6 in a useful power band and can feel responsive with paddle shifters and Sport mode, yet acceleration often produces engine noise without the satisfying rhythm of fixed gears. Some reviewers find this CVT unusually agreeable, while others call it disconnected or emotionless. More importantly, owners report that regular CVT-fluid changes can support dependable service, but failures around 80,000–100,000 miles and repairs near $6,000 remain serious ownership concerns.

Nissan Maxima (2023)

Fuel Economy Costs

Fuel economy is acceptable for a powerful V6 sedan, not especially competitive for daily efficiency. The Maxima is rated around 20 mpg city and 30 mpg highway, or 24 mpg combined, and its 18-gallon fuel tank helps preserve reasonable highway range. In practice, four-cylinder, hybrid, and some turbocharged rivals will usually require fewer fuel stops and cost less to run. Premium fuel further raises expenses, so the V6’s effortless performance is best viewed as a deliberate comfort and enjoyment trade-off.

Ride And Handling

The Maxima feels composed and more substantial than a typical family sedan. Its sport-tuned suspension, especially in the SR, can handle rough pavement better than its sporty styling suggests, while the quiet ride suits long trips. Reviewers also note strong braking and surprisingly capable grip, but the car is not a true sports sedan. Front-wheel drive and some body roll reduce cornering confidence, and steering feedback ranges from heavy or vague to pleasantly hydraulic depending on trim and driving conditions.

Nissan Maxima (2023)

V6 Acceleration

The Maxima’s naturally aspirated V6 makes everyday merging feel unusually effortless. Its 300-hp 3.5-liter V6 delivers strong, smooth acceleration without waiting for a turbo to build boost, and listed testing puts 0–60 mph at about 5.8 seconds. Passing power is a genuine strength, especially on highways, and reviewers consistently praise the engine’s refinement and growl. The limitation is that the front-wheel-drive layout can struggle to fully exploit that output, particularly in poor weather.

Nissan Maxima (2023)

Cabin Comfort Quality

The Maxima’s cabin is one of its strongest reasons to consider it over an Altima or Camry. Supportive leather front seats, available heating and ventilation, and a quiet interior create a convincingly near-luxury atmosphere. Platinum trim adds quilted leather and richer finishing, while the 11-speaker Bose system receives particularly favorable feedback. The standard 8-inch touchscreen, navigation, and smartphone integration are useful, but the interface feels dated and Apple CarPlay is wired, so the cabin’s upscale materials outshine its technology.

Nissan Maxima (2023)

Rear Space And Trunk

The Maxima works for four adults, but it is less practical than its exterior size suggests. Its 14.3-cubic-foot trunk is useful for normal luggage and errands, yet cheaper sedans such as the Altima, Accord, and Camry can offer more cargo or rear-seat room. Rear legroom is listed at 34.2 inches, and taller passengers may find headroom and knee space restrictive. That makes the Maxima comfortable as a front-seat-focused commuter, but a weaker choice for frequent family trips.

Nissan Maxima (2023)

Conclusion

The final Maxima makes a strong case for keeping sedans around: its 300-hp V6 delivers effortless passing power, while the composed ride, capable SR handling, and quiet, leather-lined front cabin make commuting feel unusually polished. Reviewers agree it is comfortable and quick, though not a true sports sedan; front-wheel drive and the CVT limit steering involvement, and owners’ reports of costly transmission failures make maintenance history important. Practicality is adequate rather than exceptional, with a useful trunk but a tighter rear seat than several cheaper rivals. Fuel economy is acceptable for a V6, yet four-cylinder and hybrid alternatives are easier on the wallet. This is a smart fit for drivers who value distinctive styling, highway performance, and near-luxury comfort more than maximum efficiency or space. Its strong character is balanced by real ownership compromises, supporting a favorable—but not unquestioning—recommendation.

Feature Scores Icon

Feature Scores

This reflects reviews and ratings from established critics, journalists, and users who have evaluated the item. Their opinions provide a comprehensive assessment.

Performance

Engine Power

5/5

Acceleration

4/5

Reliability & Durability

3/5

Handling & Ride Comfort

4/5

Braking Performance

4/5

Value

Purchase Price Competitiveness

3/5

Cost of Ownership

3/5

Resale Value

3/5

Feature Value

4/5

Design

Exterior Styling

5/5

Interior Ergonomics

4/5

Cargo Space

3/5

Infotainment Quality

4/5

Health

Cabin Air Quality

3/5

Material Toxicity

TBD

Safety

Crashworthiness

5/5

Active Safety Systems

5/5

Visibility & Lighting

4/5

Child Occupant Protection

4/5

Sustainability

Fuel Efficiency

3/5

Tailpipe Emissions

3/5

Recyclability

TBD

Manufacturing Footprint

TBD

Experience Style

Driver Engagement

4/5

Customization Options

4/5

Ease of Use

4/5

Ownership Convenience

4/5

Specifications Icon

Specifications

This section outlines the product's key facts, covering essential features, details, dimensions, materials, and any unique characteristics that define its functionality and usability.

Performance

Value

Design

Safety

Sustainability

Experience Style

Question Mark Icon

Frequently Asked Questions


7 Questions


Find Yours

Step 011 of 4 questions

What is your primary use for a gas-powered sedan or compact?

Answer to find your best matches.